The Gods Who Never Were

An Excerpt from the Doctoral Dissertation of Xyrelle Vantaris-9
Department of Archaeology, University of New Alexandria, Earth, 12,026 C.E.

Introduction: A Necessary Heresy

For nearly six centuries, scholars of the Late Dark Age have agreed on one central fact concerning the civilization that occupied much of Earth approximately ten thousand years ago: They worshipped many gods. Thousands of them.

Kal’el, God of Justice. Bru’swain, God of Fear and Vengeance. Zelda, Goddess of Wisdom. To-Nees Tarque, God of Fortune and Artifice. Pik-Achu, Lord of Lightning. Har-Ree Pottar, Patron of Sorcery. Mar-Te MacFlai, God of Time and Improvised Transportation.

The list stretches through forty-three volumes of Professor Elliqua Zenn’s Comprehensive Pantheon of the Pre-Collapse Peoples, and even Zenn admitted that her work was incomplete. New divine figures continue to emerge from Late Dark Age archaeological sites every decade.

Until two years ago, I believed every word of it. This dissertation will argue that we have been wrong. Not slightly wrong. Not wrong in the manner of Professor Ulysses-Q Marvan, who spent thirty years arguing that Kal’el’s sacred companion Bru’swain was actually his younger brother rather than an opposing deity. I mean fundamentally wrong.

The people of the Late Dark Age did not worship Kal’el. They did not pray to Zelda. They did not fear Bru’swain. They did not sacrifice wealth to To-Nees Tarque. Those beings were fictional. I understand what I am suggesting. My thesis adviser has reminded me seventeen times.


My interest in Late Dark Age religion began when I was nine. My mother took me to the Museum of Pre-Collapse Humanity in Old Washington, where a reconstructed temple chamber contained twelve surviving idols discovered beneath the ruins of what archaeologists believe was once a commercial center. I remember Kal’el immediately.

The figure stood perhaps twenty centimeters tall. His blue ceremonial garments were faded almost gray, but the crimson cloak had survived remarkably well. On his chest was the familiar diamond-shaped glyph that every schoolchild recognizes. “Who was he?” I asked.

My mother smiled. “The ancients believed he came from the heavens.”

That was enough. For the next twenty years, Kal’el followed me everywhere. I wrote my undergraduate thesis on the competing interpretations of his heavenly origin. Some scholars argued that Kal’el was a solar deity. Others believed he represented an idealized ruler. Professor Tovan Rhe suggested that the recurring stories of Kal’el falling from the sky preserved a cultural memory of the asteroid impacts believed to have contributed to the Fourth Global Collapse.

I considered that theory ridiculous. I still do. One can overturn six centuries of scholarship without surrendering all standards.

The surviving evidence seemed overwhelming. Images of Kal’el appeared across the North American continent and in sites throughout Europe and Asia. His sacred emblem was found on clothing, drinking vessels, children’s objects, transportation devices, jewelry, and what appeared to be banners displayed inside private homes. Some individuals permanently marked his symbol into their skin. What else were we supposed to conclude? The ancients worshipped him.

Bru’swain was even more fascinating because he appeared to have been a god designed specifically to frighten people into behaving properly. His image was almost always nocturnal. Ancient texts associated him with criminals, caves, winged mammals, vengeance, and a metropolis called Got-Ham. The prevailing interpretation held that worshippers of Kal’el and Bru’swain belonged to related theological traditions within the religion scholars call Dee-Sea.

The Mar-Vel tradition appeared later in the archaeological record and eventually became its chief competitor. This theological rivalry must have been enormous. Artifacts were everywhere. Shrines dedicated to these beings occupied entire rooms in some homes. Excavated collections have contained hundreds of painted books depicting their adventures. Scholars have uncovered statues ranging from miniature household idols to enormous figures displayed in public commercial spaces.

Some citizens wore clothing bearing divine symbols. Others dressed as the gods themselves. For decades, this last practice was interpreted as ritual possession. The most famous example comes from the annual pilgrimage to Sandy Aygo.


We know little about Sandy Aygo itself. The city likely disappeared during the First Pacific Submersion, but surviving records indicate that tens of thousands of pilgrims traveled there annually. The purpose of the pilgrimage has generated considerable debate. Ancient photographic materials show participants wearing elaborate representations of Kal’el, Won-Dar Wooman, Har-Lee Quinn, Spi-Darman, Thorr, and thousands of lesser divine figures.

Some scholars believe these costumes allowed worshippers to symbolically embody the gods. Others suggest the festival celebrated a seasonal renewal ceremony. Professor Ven Solari famously proposed that unmarried participants attended Sandy Aygo specifically to engage in ritual courtship. That theory is based almost entirely on a damaged garment reading FREE HUGS. Even armchair historians reject Solari.

Ask any amateur scholar how the Sandy Aygo pilgrimage actually worked and you will inevitably hear the same sentence: “Yeah, but how did it really happen?” I used to find that irritating. Now I find it strangely comforting.


My discovery occurred on 17 Rainfall, 12,024, at Excavation Site North Meridian-81. The site had been considered academically unremarkable. It was located beneath what had once been a suburban settlement on the eastern coast of North America. Most structures had long since decayed, although deep foundations survived beneath several meters of sediment.

We were searching for household religious artifacts. We found garbage. Literally. A sealed refuse chamber. I remember my colleague Juno Cassivar-3 complaining about the smell, which was absurd because nothing organic had survived long enough to smell like anything.

“Ten thousand years,” she said, staring into the chamber. “And somehow I’m still digging through somebody else’s trash.”

“That,” I told her, “is archaeology.”

Near the bottom of the chamber, protected inside a collapsed polymer container, we found a rectangular object. Printed paper. Almost none of it should have survived. Somehow, perhaps because the container had remained airtight before its eventual burial, portions were still legible. The cover depicted dozens of familiar gods. Kal’el stood at the center. Bru’swain beside him. Won-Dar Wooman. Aqua-Man. Flaash. The title was damaged, but three words could be reconstructed:

ENCYCLOPEDIA

COMICS

CHARACTERS

I nearly dropped it.


The word comics had appeared before. Our understanding of it was uncertain. The traditional interpretation identified comics as sacred illustrated narratives, probably intended to communicate theological teachings to populations with varying levels of literacy. The word character was more troubling.

I spent three days in the conservation chamber while technicians separated the surviving pages. Most were useless. Some contained fragments. Then we found Kal’el. His entry included the expected descriptions. His heavenly origin. His extraordinary strength. His conflict with a figure called Lex Luth-Or, traditionally interpreted as a demon associated with greed.

But halfway down the page appeared a sentence that changed my life. Only eleven words survived completely. They were enough.

“Superman is a fictional superhero created by writer Jerry Siegel and…”

Fictional. I stared at that word for a very long time. Then I laughed. I couldn’t help it. Ten thousand years of civilization had risen and fallen. Humanity had rebuilt itself after plagues and wars. We had crossed oceans, lost continents, built cities in the stratosphere, and sent colonies to Mars whose descendants now occasionally threatened to annihilate us over mining rights.

And somewhere through all of that, Kal’el had become a god. Except he never was one. He was Superman.


The implications multiplied quickly. Another page described Bru’swain.

“Batman is a fictional superhero…”

I read it six times. Zelda presented a greater challenge because our initial artifact contained only the title The Legend of Zelda. For centuries this had been interpreted as direct confirmation of her divine status. Legends, after all, belong to gods and heroes. Only later did we understand that Zelda was associated with something called a “video game.”

Digital game media has not survived from the Late Dark Age, but physical objects associated with it have. Archaeologists had long catalogued rectangular plastic relics bearing Zelda’s name and the three-triangle symbol known as the Trai-Fors. We believed they were devotional objects. They were entertainment.

The Trai-Fors wasn’t a religious symbol. At least, not originally.

By the fourth week, my dissertation had collapsed. It had been titled Syncretism Among the Heroic Pantheons of the Late Dark Age. I deleted three hundred pages. My adviser nearly experienced a medical event.

“You cannot base a doctoral thesis on eleven words,” Professor Omnira Vale-77 told me.

“Twenty-three,” I said.

“What?”

“The Bru’swain fragment gives us another twelve.”

Professor Vale stared at me. I had been told she once made a graduate student cry merely by adjusting her glasses. “I fail to see how that improves your situation.”

“It doubles my evidence.”

Her glasses moved. I nearly cried.


The problem was not merely Kal’el. Once I knew what I was looking for, everything began to make sense differently. Ancient worshippers had not erected temples to these figures. They had built cinemas. The enormous illuminated representations of the gods weren’t religious visions. They were projected entertainment. The printed sacred texts weren’t sacred. They were comic books. The household idols weren’t idols. They were toys.

This last conclusion has attracted particular hostility. No serious scholar enjoys being told that the sacred effigies occupying half the Museum of Pre-Collapse Humanity were once sold to children. The Fun-Ko figures have been especially controversial. Their enlarged heads and uniformly black eyes inspired an entire school of religious interpretation. The prevailing view held that the disproportionate skull represented divine intelligence while the dark eyes symbolized eternity.

I am increasingly convinced they simply thought the figures looked cute. Professor Zenn has stopped answering my messages.


Mar-Vel and Dee-Sea were not churches. They were commercial publishers. Dis-Nee was not an expansionist religious empire. Well. Perhaps I should phrase that more carefully. My committee objected to the joke the first time.

The evidence suggests Dis-Nee was an entertainment corporation that acquired ownership of numerous fictional traditions. This explains why archaeological records previously interpreted as evidence of theological conquest show Mar-Vel figures suddenly appearing under the Dis-Nee name.

The entity called Star Wars appears to have undergone a similar absorption. The ancient god Luuk Skai-Walkar was never worshipped as Lord of Celestial Balance. Darth Vaydar was not his underworld counterpart. And the tiny green sage Yo-Da was not, despite Professor Kelm’s four-volume argument, a fertility god. I admit that one hurt. I rather liked the fertility-god theory.


My colleagues accuse me of arrogance. Perhaps they’re right. There is something inherently arrogant about telling generations of scholars that they misunderstood everything. But there is also arrogance in refusing new evidence because too many books have already been written. Professor Vale asked me during my preliminary defense what I expected historians to do with six centuries of scholarship.

“Revise it,” I said.

She looked horrified. Academics love discovering new knowledge right up until it makes their old knowledge obsolete. The greatest resistance comes from one question. If these figures weren’t gods, why did the people invest so much in them? Why did millions gather to see their stories? Why did people dress like them? Why did they collect their images? Why did adults spend enormous amounts of money acquiring objects associated with imaginary characters?

Surely, my critics argue, this indicates worship even if the ancients themselves used another word. I reject that conclusion. People invest meaning in stories without believing those stories literally happened. Perhaps Kal’el represented justice because people wanted justice. Perhaps Bru’swain allowed them to explore fear because they experienced fear. Perhaps Zelda’s stories appealed to people who valued courage and wisdom. A society does not need to believe a story is true for the story to matter. That may be the most human thing I have learned from them.


There is, however, an uncomfortable implication. If we were wrong about them, what else are we wrong about? That question has become the true subject of this dissertation. Modern archaeology prides itself on evidence. We reconstruct cultures from fragments. A broken vessel. A burial site. A damaged inscription. A structure whose purpose vanished with the people who built it. Then we assemble those fragments into a story and call the story history. Usually, it is the best story the evidence allows. But best is not the same as true.

Ten thousand years ago, scholars of the Late Dark Age almost certainly did the same thing to civilizations that came thousands of years before them. Their surviving texts discuss ancient Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, Mesopotamians, and cultures whose names we can no longer translate. They identified temples. They named gods. They assigned meaning to objects whose makers had been dead for millennia. How often were they right? How often were they standing in the ancient equivalent of a shopping center and confidently declaring it sacred ground? I no longer find that question amusing. Not entirely.


Last month, while cataloguing material from the same refuse chamber, Juno found another fragment. It predates the Kal’el encyclopedia by several thousand years. The object bears the image of a figure with the head of a bird and the body of a man. Our records identify it as an Egyptian deity called Horus. I stared at it for several minutes.

Juno noticed. “You’re doing it again,” she said.

“Doing what?”

“Thinking something that will make your committee angry.”

I turned the fragment over in my hands. Ten thousand years separated me from Superman. Several thousand more separated Superman’s creators from Horus. Somewhere in that enormous stretch of time, every civilization looked backward and tried to understand the people who came before. We all had fragments. We all had theories. We all had professors who were absolutely certain.

“What if they were wrong, too?” I asked.

Juno sighed. “Xyrelle.”

“What?”

“You need to graduate.”

I looked again at the bird-headed god. Maybe Horus was worshipped exactly as our records claim. Probably. The evidence is considerable. But for the first time in my academic career, I found myself wondering what some future archaeologist might make of our own civilization. Perhaps ten thousand years from now they will excavate my dissertation. Perhaps they will misunderstand everything. Perhaps they will decide that Professor Vale was a terrifying goddess of judgment whose sacred spectacles could reduce students to tears. Honestly, I would have difficulty disproving that one.

Still, I hope whoever finds these words remembers something. Artifacts survive. Context doesn’t always survive with them. And sometimes a god is only a man in a cape. Sometimes a sacred relic was a child’s toy. Sometimes thousands of pilgrims traveled annually to Sandy Aygo not to worship at all, but simply because they loved the same stories. And sometimes the difference between mythology and entertainment is ten thousand years and one missing word.

Fictional.

Leave a Reply