There’s a moment that happens occasionally when I’m watching a science-fiction movie and everything falls apart. Maybe I’m watching a superhero leap through the air. Maybe it’s a creature attacking our heroes. Maybe two digital characters are fighting while the camera does something no physical camera could possibly do. Whatever the case, my brain suddenly stops thinking about the story and says: Oh. That’s CGI.
And that’s a problem.
Not because I have anything against computer-generated imagery. I don’t. Some of the greatest visual effects ever created would have been impossible without computers, and modern filmmakers can create worlds that previous generations couldn’t have imagined putting on screen. But the moment I start thinking about the effect instead of what the effect represents, some part of the illusion has disappeared. That’s ultimately what matters to me. Not realism. Believability.
I Don’t Need It to Be Real
Most of my favorite movies aren’t particularly concerned with reality. Back to the Future has a flying DeLorean. Ghostbusters has a 100-foot marshmallow man strolling through Manhattan. Star Wars asks me to accept an entire galaxy filled with aliens, droids, and spaceships that somehow make noise in the vacuum of space. I’m willing to meet a movie pretty far from reality.
What I need from filmmakers is enough believability to make me stop questioning what I’m seeing. I don’t need the Millennium Falcon to be physically capable of traveling through hyperspace. I need it to look like an object that has weight and history. I need scratches on the hull. I need light to hit it in a way that convinces my brain there is actually something there.
For most of cinema history, filmmakers accomplished that through practical effects because they didn’t have another option. They built miniatures. They created elaborate makeup effects. They put actors inside creature suits and constructed puppets that required teams of people to operate. They worked within limitations.
Sometimes you can see those limitations. We’ve all watched older movies where a string becomes visible if you look closely enough, or where the miniature stops looking quite so massive once your brain notices the scale. Sometimes a monster looks suspiciously like a sweaty performer who is desperately waiting for somebody to yell “Cut.”
But when those techniques work? They work. The original Star Wars. Alien. E.T.. The Thing. Predator. Ghostbusters. Blade Runner. Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Those filmmakers created impossible worlds without computers capable of generating whatever they could imagine. And sometimes I think those limitations actually helped.
There’s Actually Something There
One advantage practical effects have is embarrassingly simple. The thing exists. If an actor is standing beside a creature built by an effects team, light actually hits that creature. It casts a real shadow. If the actor touches it, his hand is touching something. If the creature is wet, the water is actually reflecting whatever lights are on the set. There are imperfections because physical objects have imperfections. Our brains are remarkably good at registering those little details, even when we aren’t consciously looking for them.
That doesn’t mean a practical effect automatically looks convincing. There is more than enough cinematic evidence to disprove that theory before lunch. I’ve seen practical spaceships where I’m fairly sure I could identify the fishing line holding them up. But a well-made practical effect begins with one enormous advantage: It already exists in the same physical space as the actor.
Think about the creature effects in John Carpenter’s The Thing. Rob Bottin and his effects team created grotesque transformations using mechanical effects, puppetry, and elaborate prosthetics. The results are deliberately unnatural, but they have physical weight. When something disgusting erupts out of something else, everyone in the scene is reacting to an object that occupies space. It feels visceral. Your brain may know intellectually that you’re watching rubber, mechanisms, and movie magic.
Another part of your brain is saying: GET THAT THING AWAY FROM ME. That’s success.
Jurassic Park Already Answered This Question
I recently wrote an entire post about how Jurassic Park transformed visual effects, so I’m not going to retell that whole story here. If I start talking about Stan Winston’s hydraulic T. rex, Phil Tippett thinking he had become extinct, and somebody plucking guitar strings beneath a Ford Explorer, we’ve officially wandered back into the other article.
But there is one lesson from Jurassic Park that belongs here because it may be the best answer anyone has ever given to the practical-versus-digital debate. The filmmakers used both.
Stan Winston’s team built enormous animatronic dinosaurs that could physically occupy the set. Industrial Light & Magic created dinosaurs digitally when the shots demanded movement the animatronics couldn’t provide. Phil Tippett, whose go-motion work was initially going to handle those wider shots, instead helped the digital animators understand how animals should move.
The techniques didn’t compete. They collaborated. I wrote in that earlier piece about the first Brachiosaurus reveal, when Alan Grant and Ellie Sattler simply stare at something that cannot possibly exist. For a few seconds, we forget we’re watching a special effect. We just believe. That’s still the standard.
The T. rex doesn’t need to be practical. It doesn’t need to be CGI. It needs to be a T. rex. Don’t make me think about the technique. Make me worry about the lawyer sitting on the toilet.
CGI Isn’t the Enemy
I want to be clear about something because discussions like this can quickly turn into Old Man Yells at Pixels. CGI is incredible. I don’t particularly care for the Avatar franchise, but I’m not going to sit here pretending those movies aren’t visually astonishing. Whatever complaints I might have about Pandora, James Cameron and the armies of visual-effects artists working with him have created a remarkably convincing digital environment.
The modern Planet of the Apes films have similarly produced characters through performance capture and digital animation that I accept as living beings while I’m watching them. I’m not sitting there thinking about polygons when Caesar is speaking. I’m thinking about Caesar.
And Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy remains another good example of filmmakers using whatever they needed to create Middle-earth. There are miniatures, prosthetics, forced perspective, digital characters and enormous computer-generated environments. The techniques change from shot to shot because the illusion is more important than ideological purity.
The problem isn’t CGI. The problem is assuming CGI should replace every other tool simply because it technically can. Because sometimes you get Rubber Neo.
Once You See Rubber Neo…
I enjoy The Matrix. The sequels? That’s more complicated.
There are moments in The Matrix Reloaded where the Wachowskis’ ambitions seem to have gotten a little too far ahead of what digital technology could convincingly accomplish in 2003. And once Neo starts looking like a rubber action figure? Good luck unseeing it.
That’s the danger. The audience stops watching Neo fight. We’re watching a visual effect of Neo fighting. Suddenly there is distance between us and the action. That doesn’t mean the artists lacked talent. Visual-effects artists can only work with the technology, source footage and resources available to them. Sometimes filmmakers are simply asking for something extraordinarily difficult. And sometimes the problem starts much higher up the food chain.
Maybe Stop Blaming the VFX Artists
This is one place where I think audiences, myself included, should be more careful. When we see bad CGI, it’s easy to say: “The CGI artists did a terrible job.” Maybe they didn’t. Perhaps the artists weren’t given enough time. Perhaps the shot changed late in production. Perhaps the studio wanted something spectacular without budgeting enough money to make spectacular happen.
VFX professionals have repeatedly discussed how inadequate planning, compressed schedules and late creative changes can damage finished work. That matters when we’re looking at a giant blockbuster and wondering why one particular effect looks like it was rendered on a Game Boy.
Maybe our first question shouldn’t be: “What were those artists doing?”
Maybe it should be: “What did the studio ask those artists to do, and how long did they give them to do it?”
We sometimes talk about CGI as though somebody presses a button labeled MAKE DRAGON and then waits for the computer to finish. There are still human beings behind those pixels.
Gandalf Should Have Someone to Talk To
Practical effects can also give actors something incredibly valuable. Another actor. Or at least a puppet. Ian McKellen’s experience making The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey offers an unusually sad example of what can happen when that physical interaction disappears. Because Gandalf needed to appear much taller than the dwarves and hobbits, McKellen sometimes had to perform separately from his castmates on a green-screen stage. Behind-the-scenes footage captured him becoming deeply frustrated by the isolation.
I remember seeing that footage and thinking how miserable it looked. Here is Gandalf. Full costume. Full beard. Ready to act. And he’s sitting alone surrounded by green. McKellen later discussed just how upsetting that experience became because acting, for him, meant interacting with other performers.
I think that speaks volumes. Pun absolutely intended.
Green screens aren’t inherently bad. Actors have been staring at marks, tennis balls and imaginary monsters forever. But I have to imagine there is a difference between being told, “There will eventually be a dragon over there,” and having some enormous animatronic head occupying enough space in front of you that your nervous system is receiving at least a little assistance.
A Galaxy You Can Touch
This is one reason I was excited when The Force Awakens promised a renewed emphasis on practical filmmaking. Whatever I ultimately think about the story of the Star Wars sequel trilogy is another discussion. Trust me. We’ll be here awhile. But I appreciated the philosophy.
The sequel films brought back physical creatures, props and sets while still using modern digital effects where necessary. BB-8 could actually roll around the set. Puppeteers could give performers something physical to interact with. It felt like Star Wars. That doesn’t mean the prequel trilogy abandoned practical filmmaking entirely. There were far more physical miniatures and sets involved in those productions than their reputation sometimes suggests.
But the movies often feel digital to me. That distinction matters.
George Lucas was understandably fascinated by the possibilities of emerging digital filmmaking. Unfortunately, I sometimes feel as though the technology itself became part of the attraction. What new environment could be built? What new digital character could share the frame with the actors? Those experiments helped push filmmaking technology forward. I just don’t always think they helped the scene. Technological possibility is not the same thing as artistic necessity.
And Now We Have the Volume
Virtual production has added another fascinating tool. Industrial Light & Magic’s StageCraft technology, popularly called “the Volume,” uses enormous LED screens to display virtual environments around the performers. Instead of putting an actor in front of a blank green wall, you can surround that performer with something approximating the finished environment while filming. That’s genuinely impressive.
Actors can see where they are supposed to be. The digital landscape can create actual reflections and interactive lighting on physical costumes and props. Filmmakers can place characters somewhere that would otherwise require an expensive or impossible location shoot. Again: Great tool.
The danger comes when a great tool becomes the answer to every question. If virtual production means you don’t need to go to the desert anymore, that’s useful. It doesn’t necessarily mean you shouldn’t go to the desert. Sometimes I want wind hitting the actors. I want dirt getting onto their clothes. I want somebody squinting because the sun is actually in his eyes. The Volume should expand filmmakers’ options. It shouldn’t shrink the world to the dimensions of a soundstage.
Fury Road and the False Choice
Mad Max: Fury Road may provide another great example of why “practical versus CGI” is the wrong argument. The movie became famous for its practical stunt work, and rightly so. Real vehicles raced across real terrain while stunt performers did things that make me question whether their health insurance came with a handwritten note from George Miller. But Fury Road also contains extensive digital work.
Landscapes were altered. Safety equipment was removed. Environments were enhanced. Shots were stitched together and manipulated. That’s not cheating. That’s filmmaking. The physical stunt provides the scene with weight. Digital tools remove limitations. Neither needs to defeat the other. They cooperate. Which sounds remarkably familiar.
Stop Pretending There’s “No CGI”
There is one modern trend I could do without. Studios sometimes become so eager to advertise practical filmmaking that you’d think CGI were a contagious disease nobody wants to admit having. “We did it for real!” Okay. That’s cool. But somebody still spent six months removing the wires.
Movies heavily marketed around practical effects can contain thousands of digital-effects shots. That doesn’t diminish the practical accomplishment. If somebody really flew a fighter jet, drove a truck through the desert or jumped off a building, that’s impressive. But so is seamlessly removing the equipment that kept that person alive. We don’t have to diminish one craft to celebrate another. The stunt performer deserves credit. So does the artist who makes the harness disappear.
The Imperfections Help
Maybe this is ultimately what I love most about practical effects. They have limitations. That sounds like an insult. I mean it as a compliment. Limitations force filmmakers to make decisions. They determine where the camera can go and how something should move. They force artists to solve physical problems. And those solutions sometimes create little imperfections.
The puppet doesn’t move exactly like a biological animal would. The miniature has a little too much texture. The monster suit bends strangely. Yet those imperfections can make an impossible thing feel more believable because they remind some primitive corner of our brains that something was physically photographed. Digital effects can achieve the same result when artists deliberately incorporate the messiness of reality. Because perfection isn’t necessarily believable. Reality is full of scratches.
Just Make Me Believe
So practical effects or CGI? Yes. That’s my answer. Give me animatronics when an animatronic creature works. Give me CGI when the camera needs to show something no physical object could accomplish. Build a miniature if that’s the best solution. Put somebody in makeup. Extend the set digitally. Erase the wires afterward. Just don’t make the technique the point.
That first Brachiosaurus in Jurassic Park still captures exactly what I want from a visual effect. I don’t watch Grant’s jaw drop and think about polygons. I don’t stop to calculate which shots involve Stan Winston and which belong to ILM. I’m looking at a dinosaur. That is the magic trick. I don’t care whether your spaceship is a six-foot miniature hanging in front of a camera or exists entirely inside a computer. I don’t care whether your monster is a performer buried under prosthetics or a digital creation assembled by hundreds of artists.
I don’t need it to be real. I need to believe it’s real. And if you’ve managed that? I probably won’t even think to ask how you did it until the credits are rolling.