Question of the Week #513

Welcome back to another Question of the Week here at The Confusing Middle! Every week, I pull another question from Gregory Stock’s The Book of Questions and attempt to figure out what my answer actually is.

Last week, Stock asked whether I could be satisfied in a marriage that was wonderful in every respect except that it completely lacked sex. After giving it some thought, my answer was yes. I think I could. Sex might be something I would want as part of a marriage, but I couldn’t imagine throwing away an otherwise extraordinary relationship simply because it wasn’t there.

Apparently Gregory Stock heard my answer and said: “Excellent. Now let’s make this weird.”

Because this week’s question is a direct follow-up: Are you able to separate sex from love? Could you be content for long satisfying your sexual needs with people other than your mate?

Well. That escalated quickly. My answer this time isn’t nearly as complicated. No. I really don’t think I could.

Apparently I Do Have a Line

Last week’s question allowed me to be fairly flexible about what a hypothetical marriage might look like. If I were married to someone I deeply loved and we had built a wonderful life together, I don’t think the absence of sex would automatically make that marriage worthless. There are other forms of intimacy. There is companionship. There is the simple comfort of knowing someone has chosen to build her life with you. I could imagine being satisfied with that.

What I have a much harder time imagining is saying: “Well, honey, since we’re not having sex anymore, maybe you should go find someone else for that.”

Even writing that sentence makes something inside me recoil. This isn’t about condemning people who have consensually non-monogamous relationships. If everyone involved understands the arrangement and genuinely wants it, those adults certainly don’t need my permission.

Research actually gives me good reason not to pretend my personal preference represents some universal formula for relationship success. A recent meta-analysis looking at 35 studies involving more than 24,000 people found no significant overall difference in relationship satisfaction or sexual satisfaction between people in monogamous and consensually non-monogamous relationships. So apparently people can make it work. Good for them. I could not.

I Didn’t Become Don Juan Since Last Saturday

I should probably repeat the disclaimer from last week’s post. I am a 46-year-old virgin. This remains true. I did not somehow transform into Don Juan during the seven days between these two questions. So when I start talking about whether sex can be separated from love, understand that I’m doing so without firsthand sexual experience. I’m not going to pretend otherwise.

But the fact that I have remained a virgin this long probably tells you something about my feelings regarding casual sex. I’m single. There is nothing preventing me, morally or contractually, from pursuing a purely sexual relationship. I haven’t. That doesn’t mean I believe everyone should make the same choices I have. It means sex has never felt casual to me.

I can’t imagine becoming that physically intimate with someone while insisting the experience has absolutely nothing to do with emotional intimacy. Maybe other people can. I still have my doubts that those two things can ever be separated completely.

Sex and Love Aren’t the Same Thing

Here’s where I need to make an important distinction. Obviously, sex and love are not synonymous. People have sex with people they don’t love. People love each other without having sex. Last week’s entire question depended on that second possibility. So I don’t mean that sexual attraction automatically equals romantic love.

What I question is whether you can repeatedly share something so physically intimate with another person and guarantee that emotion will never enter the equation. That guarantee would matter tremendously to me if I were married.

Suppose my hypothetical wife and I had stopped having sex. Maybe neither of us knows why. Maybe I’ve simply lost interest. Stock then offers the solution that she can satisfy that particular need with someone else. Even if I explicitly gave her permission, I would struggle with it.

Technically, I wouldn’t call that infidelity. If we discussed it beforehand and mutually agreed that she could have sex outside our marriage, she wouldn’t be cheating on me. But knowing that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t hurt. I think it would hurt tremendously.

What Happens When “Just Sex” Stops Being Just Sex?

Jealousy would obviously be part of my reaction. I’m not going to pretend otherwise. But jealousy wouldn’t be my only concern. I’d be afraid of what happens next. Maybe my wife finds someone with whom she has fantastic sexual chemistry. Maybe they establish boundaries. They aren’t dating. They aren’t building a life together. This is strictly about satisfying a physical need that isn’t being met inside the marriage. Okay.

What happens after the fifth time they sleep together? The twentieth? What happens when they start talking afterward? What happens when she has a terrible day and realizes she wants to tell him about it? That’s where I struggle with the premise.

Researchers have spent decades studying people’s reactions to sexual and emotional infidelity, and the findings are more complicated than the familiar claim that men care primarily about sexual betrayal while women care primarily about emotional betrayal. Studies using different methods have produced different results, and some have found substantial similarities between men’s and women’s responses. Both sexual and emotional betrayal can produce intense jealousy and feelings of threat.

That makes considerably more intuitive sense to me. Because an affair is an affair. Whether the deepest betrayal happened in a bed or through an emotional connection that displaced the marriage, something important has moved outside the relationship. Again, that’s just how I would experience it.

Marriage Means Choosing Each Other

This brings me back to something I wrote last week. I like the idea that a lasting marriage means waking up every morning and continuing to choose each other. I still believe that. Maybe that’s hopelessly traditional. I’m okay with that.

If I stood in front of someone and promised to spend the rest of my life with her, monogamy would be part of what I believed I was promising. That doesn’t mean I expect marriage to freeze two people in time. Last week I talked about how bodies change and circumstances change. Sexual desire can change, too.

Suppose I reached a point where I no longer had much interest in sex but my wife still did. My first instinct wouldn’t be to outsource the job. I would want to understand what was happening. I would want to talk about what she needed and what I needed. And assuming I was physically and emotionally capable, I would want to find ways to make sure her needs were still being met. Preferably by me. Because she would still be my wife. Her needs wouldn’t stop mattering simply because mine had changed.

What If Sex Became Impossible?

Stock’s question becomes more difficult if we remove choice from the equation. What if illness made sex impossible? What if some physical change meant my hypothetical wife and I could no longer have the sexual relationship we’d once shared? Would I then feel differently about her finding someone else? No. I don’t think I would.

And if the roles were reversed, I feel fairly certain I would choose celibacy. That may be extraordinarily easy for a lifelong virgin to say. Fair point. But I can’t imagine looking at a woman I had promised my life to and deciding that because she could no longer fulfill one particular need, I was therefore entitled to find someone else who could.

If she explicitly gave me permission? I still don’t think I would. Because the problem isn’t simply whether I’m allowed to do it. I wouldn’t want to do it.

But Is That Fair to Her?

This is probably the strongest argument against my position. Suppose my wife still wants sex. I don’t. I’m asking her to give up something meaningful to her because I cannot emotionally handle her seeking it elsewhere. Is that fair? Maybe not. That’s where I can’t pretend my answer solves the hypothetical neatly.

I would want to fight for the marriage. I would want to find some solution that allowed both of us to remain happy together. If she eventually told me that she needed the freedom to pursue sexual relationships with other people, I would want to try to understand that. I might even try to accept it for her sake. But knowing myself as I do now? I don’t think I could sustain it.

Eventually, I suspect the knowledge would eat away at me. And if that meant the marriage ended, that would be devastating. But I think I would rather face that painful truth than spend years pretending I was comfortable with an arrangement that was slowly tearing me apart.

Please Don’t Tell Me About Steve

Then there’s the practical question of how much I would want to know. Would I want a “don’t ask, don’t tell” arrangement? Would that somehow make things easier? Nope.

Because then my imagination gets involved. She’s going somewhere after work. Is she meeting someone? She seems particularly happy today. Is there a reason? She’s texting. Is that him? Congratulations. I have apparently transformed my own marriage into a psychological thriller.

But knowing everything sounds worse. I don’t need his name. I don’t need his occupation. I certainly don’t want to meet him. “Hi, Aaron. This is Steve. Steve is handling Tuesdays.” Absolutely not. And yet, not knowing would probably gnaw away at my soul. Which is another pretty good indication that consensual non-monogamy is not for me.

Other People Apparently Make This Work

Here’s where I want to be careful. My inability to imagine being happy in an open marriage doesn’t mean open marriages cannot be happy. Consensual non-monogamy isn’t simply another term for cheating. The defining distinction is that the people involved have agreed to the arrangement rather than one partner secretly violating the expectations of the relationship.

And this isn’t some vanishingly rare phenomenon. Research using two large U.S. samples found that roughly one in five participants reported having engaged in consensual non-monogamy at some point in their lives. More importantly, research comparing relationship satisfaction doesn’t support a simple hierarchy where monogamous relationships are automatically healthier or happier.

So I’m not interested in pointing at someone else’s marriage and declaring: “You’re doing marriage wrong!”

I have enough trouble figuring out hypothetical marriages in Gregory Stock’s book. But I can acknowledge that something works for other people while recognizing that it wouldn’t work for me. That’s where I land here.

Last Week Was About Sex. This Week Is About Exclusivity.

I think that’s what these two questions have helped me figure out. Last week I said I could live without sex. This week I’ve realized that doesn’t mean I could live without exclusivity. If I loved someone enough to marry her, I would want the physical and emotional intimacy of that relationship to remain ours. If circumstances changed and sex disappeared, I would rather figure out how to navigate that loss together than start inviting other people into that part of our lives.

Maybe that’s idealistic. Maybe my answer would look completely different if I had spent twenty years married to someone and actually faced these circumstances. That’s the limitation of every question in The Book of Questions. I can only answer as the person sitting here today. And the person sitting here today doesn’t think he can separate sex from love completely.

More importantly, he doesn’t think he could happily watch the woman he loves try. So, Gregory Stock, you got me. Last week you offered me a wonderful sexless marriage and I said I’d take the deal. Then you turned the page and showed me the fine print. Apparently I should have read the whole contract first.

Your Turn

Now I’m curious where everyone else lands. Are you able to separate sex from love? Could you be content for long satisfying your sexual needs with people other than your mate?

What if your partner were the one seeking sex elsewhere? Would knowing you had agreed to the arrangement eliminate the feeling of betrayal, or would jealousy still creep in? Could you remain emotionally secure knowing that your partner was physically intimate with someone else? And if sex disappeared from an otherwise loving relationship, would you rather accept celibacy, consider opening the relationship, or decide that the relationship could no longer meet your needs?

There probably isn’t one answer that works for everybody. There certainly isn’t one that Gregory Stock is going to let us reach comfortably. Let me know where you land in the comments.

Feature Photo by Timur Weber

Leave a Reply