
Welcome back to Rewatching Smallville, my weekly dive into the iconic series that explores Clark Kent’s journey before becoming Superman. Whether you’re a long-time fan or new to the show, you’re invited to join in each Tuesday as I revisit episodes and share my thoughts and observations. Be sure to share your own memories and theories in the comments below!
“Crimson,” the thirteenth episode of Season Six and the 123rd episode overall, originally aired on February 1, 2007. Written by Brian Peterson and Kelly Souders and directed by Glen Winter, the episode brings red kryptonite back into Clark’s life for the first time in a while, except this time Clark isn’t the first person affected by it.
I’ve always enjoyed the occasional appearance of Red-K Clark. The show has been smart enough not to overuse him, so whenever “Kal” emerges, Tom Welling gets a chance to play a version of Clark who has absolutely no interest in doing the right thing simply because it is the right thing to do. It reminds me of what Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel could do whenever Angelus showed up. You obviously didn’t want Angelus hanging around permanently, but there was always a certain fun in watching an actor who usually played the hero suddenly cut loose.
“Crimson” takes that idea and adds an extra ingredient: Lois Lane. Apparently Valentine’s Day in Smallville needed more danger.
Love Potion Number Red
The episode opens with Clark and Chloe discovering that the Talon has been transformed for Valentine’s Day. Clark is not exactly feeling the love. Lana is preparing to marry Lex, Oliver has left town, and romance in general appears to be doing what romance usually does on Smallville: making everybody miserable. Jimmy decides this is the perfect moment to play matchmaker. His candidates are Lois and Clark.
Chloe reacts to the idea with disbelief, but Jimmy points out that the two have chemistry. He isn’t wrong. Tom Welling and Erica Durance have had chemistry since Lois arrived at the beginning of Season Four. Even when Clark and Lois are doing nothing more romantic than irritating each other, there has always been an energy between them that feels fundamentally different from Clark’s relationship with Lana. Clark and Lana have spent years staring wistfully across rooms at one another. Clark and Lois actually seem like they might enjoy being in the same room.
That doesn’t mean either one is ready to acknowledge it. Lois has just broken up with Oliver. Clark remains emotionally chained to Lana with a strength that would probably impress Jor-El. When Lois and Clark realize Jimmy has attempted to set them up, both reject the idea immediately. Naturally, this means they will be making out before the next commercial break.
Lois meets a woman named Star, who offers her lipstick made with red meteor rock. The lipstick causes Lois to become infatuated with the first man she sees, who happens to be Clark. Interestingly, the idea of Lois Lane wearing red-kryptonite lipstick wasn’t invented for Smallville. Superman’s Girl Friend, Lois Lane #29, published in 1961, included a story in which Lois deliberately used lipstick containing Red Kryptonite as part of a plan to help Superman escape a Kryptonite trap. The circumstances are completely different, but I appreciate whenever Smallville takes something bizarre from Superman’s long comic-book history and finds a new excuse to use it. And if you think red-kryptonite love-potion lipstick sounds ridiculous, welcome to Silver Age Superman comics. You have no idea.
Lois Lane Has Feelings
Under the lipstick’s influence, Lois becomes everything normal Lois would find humiliating. She makes Clark a mix CD. She shows up at the Kent farm dressed for a seduction attempt. She even gets a tattoo declaring “Lois & Clark Forever.” The mix CD works for me. The tattoo does not.
I understand that Lois is under the influence of something that has stripped away her normal behavior, but a permanent tattoo feels like a leap too far. If the show had previously established that Lois was someone who regularly got tattoos to commemorate important moments in her life, I might buy an uninhibited version of her deciding Clark deserved one. But normal Lois does not strike me as the kind of person who would permanently carve some guy’s name into her skin. Apparently Red K doesn’t just remove inhibitions. It also makes questionable decisions about body art.
Still, Erica Durance is terrific throughout the episode. She has always been one of the most reliable performers when Smallville leans into comedy, and watching her turn Lois’s normal confidence into completely uninhibited romantic aggression is fun precisely because it is so far removed from how Lois usually behaves.
I’m also okay with Lois being affected by Red Kryptonite in a way I wasn’t necessarily comfortable with Alicia deliberately exposing Clark to it back in “Unsafe.” Alicia knew exactly what the Kryptonite would do to Clark and chose to take away his ability to control himself. Lois has no idea what the lipstick actually is, and Clark certainly doesn’t choose what happens when she kisses him. The whole situation is magical interference with everybody’s judgment, but nobody here deliberately removes someone else’s ability to make rational choices. Then Lois kisses Clark. And Kal comes out to play.
Clark Kent, Unfiltered
Red Kryptonite has always been interesting on Smallville because it doesn’t really transform Clark into an entirely different person. It removes the barriers Clark normally keeps around himself. Martha even reminds him after everything is over that Red K strips away his inhibitions, meaning there is usually some grain of truth underneath the horrible things he says. Which is what makes this particular appearance of Kal so entertaining.
Clark Kent spends an extraordinary amount of energy suppressing what he really thinks. He doesn’t tell Martha how bothered he is by her growing closeness with Lionel. He doesn’t tell Chloe that he knows she has carried feelings for him. He doesn’t fully confront his hatred toward Lex. And despite approximately six seasons of evidence suggesting that he should probably move on, he continues refusing to accept that Lana is marrying someone else.
Red K looks at all of that emotional restraint and says, “That seems unhealthy.” Then it grabs a flamethrower.
Before Clark begins burning down his relationships, though, we get some entertaining material with Lois. She realizes that she has kissed Clark before and concludes he must be Green Arrow. This calls back to “Hydro,” when Clark impersonated Oliver to convince Lois that Oliver couldn’t possibly be the masked vigilante she suspected him of being. Red-K Clark casually tells her the truth. Of course he does.
At this point I’m barely bothered by Lois eventually forgetting the revelation. Smallville has trained me too well. Clark can reveal his powers to somebody on this show and I immediately start wondering whether we’re going with amnesia, unconsciousness, time travel, magical interference, or a convenient head injury. Memory wipes are practically a Smallville municipal service.
The Legendary Love Affair Can Wait
The CW leaned into the Clark-and-Lois implications when promoting “Crimson,” using the tagline “The Legendary Love Affair Begins Tonight.” The episode certainly brings their physical attraction closer to the surface, but “begins” is doing a lot of work there. We are still nowhere near the point where either character is prepared to acknowledge what Clark and Lois will eventually become. Contemporary episode material from The CW focused heavily on Lois’s attraction to Clark and the emergence of “bad-Clark” after their kiss.
Still, this feels significant. Clark enjoys Lois’s attention. Lois, stripped of her inhibitions, is very clearly attracted to Clark. Even before the lipstick enters the equation, Jimmy notices their chemistry. The audience certainly knows where Superman mythology says all of this will eventually lead.
Unfortunately, Lana Lang is still here. I don’t mean physically. Kristin Kreuk is obviously still part of the show and should be. I mean emotionally, because Clark apparently intends to drag this particular romantic obsession behind him until one of the tires comes off. He can have a genuinely charged encounter with Lois Lane, but the moment he sees the invitation to Lex and Lana’s engagement dinner, everything changes. And suddenly Kal has somewhere to be.
Dinner and a Show
The engagement-dinner sequence may be the most entertaining portion of “Crimson” because Clark enters a room filled with virtually every unresolved grievance he has and proceeds to address them one by one. Sometimes every family gathering needs one cynical jerk willing to say the thing everybody else is thinking. That is why Spike was so useful on Buffy. Unfortunately for everyone at the Luthor Mansion, tonight Clark is Spike.
He starts with Martha, criticizing her increasingly close relationship with Lionel and accusing her of becoming more Luthor than Kent. It’s cruel. It’s also clearly based on something Clark genuinely feels but has refused to discuss with his mother. Jonathan has not been gone all that long, and Lionel has moved increasingly close to Martha’s life. Clark doesn’t know how to process that, so regular Clark buries the discomfort. Kal does not believe in burying things.
Then he turns toward Chloe and publicly drags her years of unrequited feelings for him into the conversation. Again, cruel. Again, there is something underneath it.
I don’t think Clark secretly wants to be with Chloe. I haven’t bought that interpretation of their relationship for a long time. But Clark probably does enjoy knowing Chloe cares about him that deeply. Who wouldn’t enjoy knowing somebody thinks that highly of them, even if those feelings aren’t reciprocated? How I Met Your Mother eventually devoted an entire storyline to this concept with the idea of “keeping someone on the hook.” Clark may not consciously think, “I should keep Chloe emotionally available in case I need her.” But Kal seems perfectly happy to point out that Clark likes having the option. Happy Valentine’s Day, Chloe.
Still With the Lana Thing?
Then Clark announces Lana’s pregnancy to the entire room. Lex is furious. Lana is humiliated. Everyone else probably begins wondering whether throwing Clark through a window would violate dinner etiquette. Clark ultimately takes Lana back to the Kent barn, where we discover that the old Clark-and-Lana feelings are still very much alive. Because apparently we needed confirmation.
I understand why Clark feels this way. I understand why the writers are not simply going to flip a switch and have him stop caring about Lana because Lois Lane has arrived. Relationships don’t work like that, and Clark has spent most of his adolescence defining Lana as the girl he believes will make everything right. But I am tired.
We just watched “Labyrinth,” where the Phantom nearly convinced Clark to surrender his entire identity by offering him an ordinary life with Lana. Now we get “Crimson,” where Red-K Clark crashes her engagement dinner and begs her not to marry Lex. Clark, buddy. Please.
Lana kissing him back only makes the entire triangle worse because it confirms that she hasn’t moved on either. She is preparing to marry Lex while still carrying unresolved feelings for Clark. Clark wants Lana while beginning to show obvious attraction toward Lois. Lex wants Lana while continuing to define part of his relationship with Clark through jealousy and competition.
Has a love triangle ever improved anyone’s life? Television loves them. Movies love them. Literature has been using them forever. Somewhere, surely, somebody in the history of humanity has lived through one that didn’t make every person involved miserable. I would like to meet them.
Lex and Lana Remain Deeply Uncomfortable
I have never liked Lex and Lana together. Part of that comes from the simple history of these characters. When Smallville began, Lana was a freshman in high school while Lex was already an adult businessman running the local LuthorCorp plant. Even setting exact ages aside, the difference in life experience has always made their eventual romance feel uncomfortable to me.
And this is hardly Lana’s first questionable age-gap situation. Whitney Fordman was a senior while Lana was a freshman. Jason Teague became an assistant football coach at Smallville High while continuing a relationship with Lana, who was still a student. Straight to jail, Jason. Now we have Lex, and the relationship becomes increasingly unpleasant as Season Six continues. The final scene of “Crimson” adds another sinister layer when Dr. Langston indicates that Lana’s pregnancy is not developing normally and Lex clearly knows something she does not. That is not exactly the foundation upon which healthy marriages are built.
Meanwhile, Lex’s confrontation with Clark in the barn gives us another ugly milestone in the death of their friendship. Clark tells Lex that if he had known what Lex would become, he never would have saved him after the bridge accident all those years ago. That is brutal. The pilot built their friendship from that rescue. Six seasons later, Clark is essentially saying he wishes he had allowed Lex to die. Red Kryptonite may be talking, but the resentment behind those words is real.
Lana Finally Notices the Obvious
One of the more important developments comes when Lex attacks Clark with a chisel and Lana later discovers that the metal has bent. She keeps it. Finally. I realize Clark has done everything short of printing business cards that say CLARK KENT: SECRETLY SUPERHUMAN, but it has taken Lana an astonishing amount of time to seriously investigate what is happening around him.
Honestly, several characters should have figured this out by now. Lex should know. Lois should probably know, and she has only been around since Season Four. Jimmy has been here for part of one season, and I’m already prepared to argue that he should be suspicious.
Clark has an overwhelming compulsion to help people and possesses nowhere near the caution necessary to keep that ability secret indefinitely. Add all the occasions when he has been drugged, possessed, infected, magically influenced, or exposed to Red Kryptonite and has simply stopped caring who sees what he can do, and it is frankly remarkable that Smallville does not have a neighborhood Facebook group dedicated to discussing Clark Kent.
But Lana has the chisel now. And instead of immediately forgetting everything twenty minutes later, she actually keeps the evidence. Progress!
Jimmy Has a Point. Sort Of.
While Clark is detonating every relationship in his immediate vicinity, Jimmy and Chloe are having problems of their own. Jimmy believes Chloe is still too emotionally invested in Clark. He points out that she continually makes excuses for Clark’s behavior and suggests that, if she were forced to choose between them, she would choose Clark. He isn’t entirely wrong.
The problem is that Jimmy has not been in Chloe’s life long enough for me to think he has earned the right to demand that kind of priority. Chloe and Clark have been through years of life-or-death situations together. Chloe knows Clark’s secret. She has protected him repeatedly. Their friendship existed long before Jimmy entered the picture and has survived things Jimmy doesn’t even know happened.
So yes, Jimmy has identified something real. He may just be asking the wrong question. If you date somebody with an incredibly important lifelong friendship, you don’t necessarily get to arrive six months later and demand top billing. Especially when the lifelong friend is Superman.
Why “Crimson” Works
“Crimson” is messy. That is exactly why I enjoy it. Red Kryptonite gives the writers permission to take nearly every emotional conflict simmering through Season Six and throw it into the same episode. Clark resents Martha’s relationship with Lionel. Chloe’s feelings for Clark remain an issue in her relationship with Jimmy. Clark hates what Lex has become. Lana is still emotionally tied to Clark while preparing to marry Lex. Lois and Clark are beginning to show the first unmistakable sparks of something neither of them is ready to acknowledge. Then Kal walks into the room and starts lighting matches.
Not every part works equally well. The tattoo is ridiculous. The Lex-and-Lana relationship remains uncomfortable. And Clark’s inability to move past Lana is becoming one of those storytelling choices where I understand the character motivation while simultaneously wanting to shake him by the shoulders.
But “Crimson” is fun precisely because Tom Welling gets to temporarily stop playing the Clark who absorbs everyone else’s problems and start playing the Clark who creates them. And underneath all the chaos, two things move forward. Lana finally has physical evidence that Clark is not what he appears to be. And Clark now knows there is something between himself and Lois that neither one is ready to deal with. Of course Lois remembers almost none of it. Because this is Smallville. Naturally.
Next Time on Rewatching Smallville
Next week, Lana has questions. Considering she has finally started collecting actual evidence instead of accepting Clark’s eighty-seventh explanation involving convenient timing and remarkable upper-body strength, that could become a problem. But before she can devote herself entirely to figuring out why a metal chisel bends when someone tries to stab Clark Kent, she has another issue to deal with. Someone is stalking her.
So join me next Tuesday for “Trespass,” when Lana Lang finds herself in danger, Clark inevitably appears wherever he shouldn’t possibly be able to appear, and maybe somebody will finally start asking the obvious question.
What did you think of “Crimson”? Do you enjoy seeing Clark under the influence of Red Kryptonite? Were you already sold on the chemistry between Clark and Lois by this point? And was Kal’s engagement-dinner tirade cruel, brutally honest, or a little of both? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Loved this episode!
LikeLiked by 1 person