I recently rewatched Close Encounters of the Third Kind, Steven Spielberg’s 1977 science-fiction classic about humanity making peaceful contact with extraterrestrial life. I still love this movie.
The effects remain astonishing. John Williams’ score is magnificent. The final encounter at Devil’s Tower remains one of the most beautiful sequences Spielberg has ever put on film. And Richard Dreyfuss gives an incredible performance as Roy Neary, an ordinary working-class guy whose entire understanding of the universe is shattered after he encounters something impossible on a dark Indiana road.
But watching Close Encounters as a grown man rather than the adolescent who first fell in love with the movie, I found myself focusing on something I had never really considered this seriously before. Roy Neary is kind of a terrible husband. And by the end of the movie? Dude just straight-up abandons his kids.
I Understand, Roy. Really, I Do.
To be fair to Roy, something genuinely extraordinary happens to him. He’s an electrical lineman sent out during a massive power outage when he experiences a close encounter with a UFO. The encounter leaves one side of his face badly burned and completely upends his understanding of reality. Afterward, he becomes consumed by an image he cannot explain. He sees the same mysterious shape everywhere and compulsively tries to recreate it.
Mashed potatoes. Clay. Eventually half the landscaping.
This is not simply some middle-aged guy who gets bored with suburban life and decides he would rather spend his evenings hunting UFOs. Something has happened to Roy. That distinction matters.
The movie eventually reveals that other people who have experienced similar encounters are receiving the same mental image. What Roy is obsessively recreating is Devil’s Tower in Wyoming. Whatever intelligence is behind the UFO phenomenon appears to have planted that location into the minds of the people it wants to draw there. So yes, I sympathize with him.
Imagine experiencing something that proves, beyond any reasonable doubt, that humanity is not alone in the universe. You know what you saw. You know it was real. Yet everyone around you has to process your story according to everything they previously understood about reality. Then imagine something inside your head constantly telling you that this shape means something. I might start sculpting mashed potatoes, too. But there is a point where sympathy runs into personal responsibility. Roy blasts through that point and keeps going.
Ronnie Thinks They’re Having a Date
The moment that really changed the movie for me during this latest viewing isn’t Roy throwing shrubbery through the kitchen window. We’ll get there. It happens earlier, when Roy takes his wife and children out at night to watch the sky. Ronnie thinks her husband has done something romantic. That little misunderstanding hit me differently this time.
Roy has been acting strangely since his encounter. His wife knows something is wrong. Their relationship is becoming increasingly strained. Then he loads everyone into the car and takes them out together at night. For a moment, Ronnie thinks this is about them.
Roy brushes her off because, of course, he isn’t there for Ronnie. He’s looking for the UFOs. That scene suddenly made me see their marriage differently. When I was younger, I tended to experience the story almost entirely from Roy’s perspective. Ronnie was the wife who didn’t understand. She wanted Roy to forget what happened and return to normal life when we, the audience, knew he was right.
There really are aliens. There really is something calling him. Devil’s Tower really does matter. But Ronnie doesn’t know any of that. From her perspective, her husband came home one night with half his face burned and began behaving increasingly erratically. He becomes emotionally distant. He loses his job. He becomes obsessed with strange shapes he cannot explain. Eventually, the man starts dismantling the yard. Ronnie isn’t failing Roy because she refuses to appreciate the majesty of first contact. She is scared. I don’t blame her.
Let’s Talk About Teri Garr
There is another important consideration here. Roy Neary is married to peak Teri Garr. This woman was an LA 10 and, arguably, a Muncie 14.
Roy. Buddy. What are we doing?
Obviously, the actual moral problem with Roy’s behavior is not that his wife happens to be extremely attractive. He would owe Ronnie exactly the same loyalty if she looked like the third runner-up at the Muncie Harvest Festival. But there is something underneath the joke that gets at what bothers me about Roy. He has a life.
It isn’t presented as perfect. The Neary household is loud and chaotic. Roy and Ronnie argue. Their kids are kids, which means Spielberg wisely portrays them as small human beings apparently dedicated to generating noise and making their parents tired. But this is a family.
Roy has a wife who loves him and three children who depend on him. He has a job. They have a home. There is every reason to believe that, before the UFO encounter, Roy expected this to be his life. Then something extraordinary enters it. Suddenly, everything ordinary becomes invisible. Including Ronnie.
The Garden Comes Inside
Eventually, Roy’s obsession completely takes over. After seeing the mysterious shape everywhere, he begins constructing an enormous model inside the house. He tears up dirt, plants and shrubbery from the yard and starts hauling everything through the windows. This is where Ronnie reaches her breaking point.
Again, try watching this scene without the knowledge the audience possesses. We know Roy is right. Ronnie doesn’t. She sees her husband behaving in a way that has become genuinely frightening. There are children in the house. Roy is destroying their home while ranting about something he cannot adequately explain. So Ronnie takes the kids and leaves. I’m not relieved for her. I’m sad for her.
This woman built a life with Roy. We don’t know much about their history before the movie begins, but they are married with three children. It seems reasonable to assume neither one entered that arrangement expecting Ronnie to eventually flee the family home because Roy had filled the living room with the backyard.
And Roy does chase after them. For a minute. Then he goes back inside. Back to Devil’s Tower. That bothered me more than anything. His wife has just driven away with his children because his behavior frightened them out of their own home. And Roy returns to the model. Where is the remorse? Where is the realization that whatever is happening to him has just cost him his family? He has become so consumed by the extraordinary that he no longer seems capable of recognizing the value of everything he already had.
Is Roy Under Alien Influence?
There is one defense of Roy that I don’t think we can dismiss. How much of this is actually his choice?
The Devil’s Tower image isn’t something Roy invents. It appears to have been placed into his consciousness by the extraterrestrials. Jillian Guiler experiences the same compulsion. Other people ultimately respond to the same subliminal summons. Roy has effectively been altered.
I considered describing his behavior as an addiction, but I’m not sure that quite fits. “Unhealthy obsession” feels closer because the extraterrestrial influence makes this unlike any ordinary compulsive behavior. Still, influence is not complete control. Roy makes choices along the way.
He could communicate with Ronnie better. He could recognize how frightening his behavior has become. He could stop throwing shrubbery through windows long enough to appreciate that his wife is not unreasonable for wondering whether everyone in the house is safe. The aliens may have put Devil’s Tower into Roy’s head. They didn’t make him stop caring about how his actions affected the people around him. Understanding what happened to Roy helps me sympathize with him. It doesn’t excuse everything he does.
And Then There’s Jillian
This becomes even more obvious once we compare Roy with Jillian Guiler, played by Melinda Dillon. Jillian has also been touched by whatever is happening. She draws Devil’s Tower obsessively without understanding what it means. There is one fairly significant difference between her motivation and Roy’s. The aliens took her kid.
Roy saw lights in the sky and got half his face sunburned. Jillian watched extraterrestrials abduct her little boy from their house. So when these two eventually realize the mysterious image represents Devil’s Tower and decide they have to get there, Jillian’s quest immediately feels more urgent to me.
Roy wants to know: Why am I seeing this giant hunk of rock?
Jillian wants to know: WHERE THE HELL IS MY KID?
I know which one has me emotionally invested. And then Roy kisses her. Roy. Come on.
This Is Not a Romance
That kiss bothered me considerably more during this viewing. I don’t see a romance between Roy and Jillian. I see a woman whose child has disappeared under circumstances no other human being could possibly understand. She is confused, frightened, and emotionally devastated. A piece of her is missing.
Roy, meanwhile, has recently frightened his wife and children into leaving him and has made remarkably little effort to repair that damage. Now he is kissing a woman he barely knows. No. I’m not giving you this one, Roy. As far as I’m concerned, that is cheating.
More importantly, I don’t think the movie needs the moment. Roy and Jillian already share something incredibly intimate without making it romantic. They have both experienced something impossible. They understand one another in a way the other people in their lives cannot. That connection is enough.
Trying to introduce even a fleeting romantic element cheapens it, particularly because Jillian’s emotional priority is never ambiguous. She wants Barry. Her son. Which brings us to the biggest problem I now have with the ending.
One Parent Comes Back. One Parent Leaves.
Jillian reaches Devil’s Tower because she wants her child back. Roy reaches Devil’s Tower because he wants answers. Both get what they want. Barry is returned. Roy leaves Earth. The more I think about those two outcomes together, the stranger the supposedly triumphant ending becomes.
Jillian has spent the movie trying desperately to reunite her family. Roy willingly abandons his.
When the government personnel prepare a group of volunteers to board the extraterrestrial ship, Roy is eventually welcomed forward. The little gray aliens gather around him, and Spielberg shoots the moment with such overwhelming wonder that it practically feels like they are declaring: It is the chosen one!
And for years, I bought it. Good for Roy! He made it! He’s going to see the universe!
Watching it now? Dude. You have children. What happens to Ronnie? Does she eventually return to the house and discover that Roy has vanished? Does she walk into the living room and find half the garden inside but no husband? How long before anyone realizes Roy is missing? What does she tell the kids? “Daddy had some things he needed to work through, so he moved to Alpha Centauri”? The movie treats Roy boarding the ship as transcendence. From Ronnie’s perspective, her husband simply disappears.
Spielberg Eventually Saw It, Too
What makes this interpretation especially interesting is that Steven Spielberg himself eventually changed his perspective on Roy’s ending. Spielberg made Close Encounters before becoming a parent. In a 1997 making-of documentary, he reflected that he would not make the same choice again after having a family of his own. He later reiterated that point, explaining that when he originally wrote and directed the movie he had no dependents in his life.
I love that. Not because it proves my interpretation is “correct.” It proves that our relationship with a movie can change because we change. Spielberg was looking at Roy differently twenty years later. So am I nearly fifty years after the movie was released.
I don’t have a wife and children myself, but decades of life experience have still changed how I understand the responsibility Roy carries. The adolescent version of me saw a man invited to explore the universe. The grown man sees what he leaves behind. Both interpretations are sitting inside the same movie.
Hello? Hello? HELLOHELLOHELLO!
None of this changes how much I love the final sequence. Good grief, it is beautiful. The enormous mothership looming over Devil’s Tower remains breathtaking, and the effects work holds up remarkably well nearly half a century later. Close Encounters received an Academy Award nomination for its visual effects, with the credited team including Roy Arbogast and Douglas Trumbull.
Then there is the musical conversation. Humanity communicates with the visitors through five notes. It is one of the most iconic ideas in the movie. Although watching it this time, I started wondering how much information we are actually conveying.
Maybe those five notes mean: “Hello.”
Then we play them again. Hello.
The aliens answer. Excellent!
So naturally we play it faster. Hello!
Faster. HelloHelloHello!
Eventually the entire landing site becomes the interstellar equivalent of two people who don’t speak the same language smiling aggressively at each other while repeating the one phrase they both know. And somehow Spielberg makes it magnificent. That is the power of this movie.
I Still Love Roy’s Journey. I Just Don’t Approve of It.
None of this ruins Close Encounters of the Third Kind for me. If anything, I think my changed reaction makes the movie more interesting. Roy’s encounter genuinely changes him. His obsession isn’t imaginary. Devil’s Tower really is calling to him. He isn’t destroying his life in pursuit of something that turns out to be meaningless. He’s right. That’s what makes the consequences so uncomfortable.
What if the thing consuming you really is important? What if the impossible thing you’re chasing really does exist? What if everyone who thinks you’ve lost your mind is eventually proven wrong? Does that justify what you destroy getting there?
I don’t think it does.
Roy gets his answer. He gets his transcendent experience. He gets invited aboard the mothership and disappears into the stars. Ronnie gets three children and a house that probably needs significant landscaping work. Jillian, meanwhile, gets Barry back.
Maybe that’s the contrast I never fully appreciated when I was younger. Jillian encounters the extraordinary and fights her way through it because she wants her family restored. Roy encounters the extraordinary and ultimately decides it matters more than his family. I understand why. I sympathize with what happened to him. But understanding Roy Neary doesn’t require me to excuse Roy Neary.
And as those aliens lead him aboard the mothership while John Williams tells me this is one of the most beautiful moments I have ever witnessed? I’m still going to be sitting there thinking: Dude. You were married to peak Teri Garr.