There are few things comic book fans enjoy more than telling publishers that they have ruined everything. I try not to be that fan.
Comic books are built on change. The Flash who first appeared in the 1940s wasn’t Barry Allen. He was Jay Garrick, running around with a metal helmet that looked like something Mercury left behind after a particularly rough weekend. When Barry Allen arrived to kick off the Silver Age, readers were being asked to embrace an entirely new character with the same superhero name. Then Crisis on Infinite Earths came along, Barry sacrificed himself, and his former sidekick Wally West eventually became the Flash for an entire generation of readers. My generation.
So I understand intellectually that change is part of the deal. I can’t complain that a comic book character has changed simply because the version being published today isn’t exactly the version I loved when I was twelve. Otherwise, I become the guy standing outside the comic shop shouting at children because their Green Lantern has the wrong secret identity.
Still… Wally West was my Flash. That made DC’s New 52 reboot complicated for me from the beginning.
I Had Just Gotten Barry Back
The frustrating thing was that I wasn’t opposed to Barry Allen returning. Far from it.
Geoff Johns and Ethan Van Sciver’s The Flash: Rebirth brought Barry properly back into the Flash mythology after his long absence, reintroducing a character whose death in Crisis on Infinite Earths had remained one of the rare superhero deaths that actually stuck for decades. DC itself described the 2009 six-issue series as Barry’s reintroduction to the role of the Flash and an exploration of where he belonged in the modern DC Universe. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Barry’s return didn’t have to mean erasing Wally. There was room for both characters. Flash mythology had spent decades building an entire family of speedsters around the idea of legacy, and that was part of what made the franchise special.
Then came Flashpoint. Then came the New 52. Suddenly Barry Allen was unquestionably the Flash again, which I could accept. But Wally wasn’t simply somewhere else doing something different. Wally West, as I knew him, was gone. So was the family around him. His marriage to Linda Park was gone. His children, Jai and Irey, were gone. Decades of relationships and history had simply ceased to exist because the continuity had been rebuilt.
I recognize my bias here. Fans who had spent years reading the Silver and Bronze Age DC Universe probably experienced something similar when Crisis on Infinite Earths rewrote everything in the mid-1980s. The characters we love become intertwined with the period when we discovered them. That doesn’t mean every change is bad. It does mean some changes hurt.
A Flash Who Can’t Be Everywhere
By the time Robert Venditti and Van Jensen took over The Flash with issue #30 in 2014, Barry had been operating in the New 52 continuity for several years. Francis Manapul and Brian Buccellato had launched the title with The Flash #1 in September 2011, with Manapul’s spectacular artwork providing one of the strongest visual identities of the entire New 52 line.
Venditti and Jensen arrived with artist Brett Booth and inker Norm Rapmund, and DC promoted the new team by emphasizing the potentially “deadly consequences” of Barry’s speed. The change began with issue #30, while The Flash Annual #3 introduced the New 52 version of Wally West.
That brings us to “Out of Time.” The central idea is actually one of the things I like best about the story. Barry Allen is the fastest man alive. He still isn’t fast enough.
Central City is recovering from the damage caused during the Crime Syndicate’s attack, and Barry is driving himself crazy trying to repair everything. He helps people rebuild as the Flash. He works cases through the Central City Police Department. He tries to maintain relationships with the people in his life. And he keeps running out of time.
A psychologist warns Barry that his determination to do more may sound noble but isn’t necessarily healthy. If he keeps pushing himself indefinitely, eventually something will break. Barry, naturally, responds to the idea that he cannot help everybody by trying harder to help everybody. That feels right for the Flash.
Superman has confronted versions of the same problem. When you possess abilities that allow you to save people ordinary human beings could never reach, where do you draw the line? The Flash can cross Central City in seconds. Given enough comic-book physics, he can cross much more than that. But fast does not equal omnipresent. Barry has to learn that eventually. Future Barry never does.
Barry Allen Versus Barry Allen
Twenty years in the future, Barry has become obsessed with every life he failed to save. That obsession has fundamentally changed him.
The Speed Force has been damaged, and Barry has begun losing pieces of time whenever he uses his powers. He eventually traces a series of tragedies back through his life, including an accident that kills Wally West and leaves Iris badly injured. His solution is about as comic-book Barry Allen as it gets. Run backward through time and fix everything. Because that worked so well during the whole Flashpoint thing.
At first glance, there is something admirable about it. Who wouldn’t want a second chance to prevent the moments that haunt them? The problem is that Future Barry no longer believes preventing tragedy requires him to remain a hero. He becomes willing to kill.
The contrast is made particularly sharp in The Flash Annual #3. Present-day Barry explicitly explains that if he has the opportunity to save a life, he will do it. Allowing someone to die when he could prevent it would be morally equivalent to killing that person himself. Twenty years later, this same man kills Grodd and prepares to go back through time to kill his younger self.
That isn’t Barry becoming more heroic. It’s Barry becoming more dangerous. And while I understand what Venditti and Jensen are doing with the character, this is also where the storyline begins losing me. Barry Allen is fundamentally hopeful. During Blackest Night, that quality was made unusually literal when Barry temporarily received a Blue Lantern ring, drawing upon the part of the emotional spectrum associated with hope.
That doesn’t mean Barry can never become angry, frightened, or damaged. Hopeful characters are only interesting if there are circumstances capable of testing that hope. But Future Barry crosses far enough into darkness that I stop seeing him as an inevitable future version of Barry Allen and start seeing him as a warning built from Barry-shaped parts. Maybe that’s the point. It just isn’t a version of the character I particularly enjoy spending time with.
The New 52 Had a Darkness Problem
That reaction goes beyond The Flash. One of my recurring issues with the New 52 was a sense that DC occasionally equated making something darker with making it more sophisticated. Obviously that wasn’t true of every book or every creative team. There was some excellent work produced under the New 52 banner. But the overall universe often felt harsher.
History had been compressed. Relationships disappeared. Legacy became less important because so many of the characters who represented that legacy were suddenly missing. For somebody who had grown up loving the interconnected DC Universe of the late 1980s through the 2000s, that loss was difficult to ignore.
Which is why I don’t think it’s coincidental that when DC launched its Rebirth initiative in 2016, the publisher itself emphasized legacy, honoring what had come before and, most notably, hope. That sounded very familiar to readers who had spent several years saying something felt missing. The New 52 had given DC a fresh starting point. Eventually, DC seemed to realize that freshness didn’t have to require throwing away everything that had made those characters worth following in the first place.
Wally West, But Not My Wally West
The New 52 eventually introduced Wally West into its continuity through this era of The Flash, and I remember being glad that some version of Wally finally existed again. But it wasn’t the Wally I knew. I want to make an important distinction here because some of the discussion surrounding this version of Wally became wrapped up in the fact that the character was Black. That never bothered me. The race of the character was not the problem.
My problem was that everything associated with the Wally West I had followed for years had vanished. His marriage was gone. His children were gone. The life he had built as the Flash was gone. This new Wally is introduced as Iris West’s troubled nephew, initially hostile toward the Flash because he blames him for what happened to his uncle Daniel. Barry gradually becomes involved in the teenager’s life at Iris’s request, and the future storyline eventually reveals just how important Barry will become to Wally.
Eventually, Wally becomes a speedster himself. There’s a nice idea buried in that relationship. Barry influences this angry young man enough that Wally eventually becomes a hero, and the future Wally is willing to sacrifice himself to save Barry and repair the Speed Force. Taken entirely on its own terms, that works. But I wasn’t reading it in a vacuum. Every time the comic said “Wally West,” I had decades of another Wally West sitting in my head. That may not have been fair to the new character. It was unavoidable.
Central City Still Feels Like Home
One place where I think this run works considerably better is Central City itself. The city matters. That is essential for certain superheroes. Gotham City is inseparable from Batman. Metropolis is part of Superman’s identity. Central City should matter to the Flash beyond providing buildings for him to run past at increasingly implausible speeds.
Here, the city is recovering from disaster. People are frustrated with the Flash because he wasn’t there when they needed him. The police department is overwhelmed. Criminals take advantage of the chaos. Barry internalizes all of it. That helps sell his downward trajectory because his guilt isn’t abstract. He can run through neighborhoods and literally see places where he believes he failed.
The storyline also makes good use of Barry’s career. Barry Allen isn’t a guy who occasionally remembers he works as a forensic scientist whenever the plot needs access to police evidence. Barry Allen is a forensic scientist. It is as much a part of his identity as being the Flash.
Throughout “Out of Time,” the police investigation involving stolen supervillain weapons runs alongside the superhero story. Barry approaches mysteries analytically. His professional instincts inform how he operates in costume. That’s Barry Allen. Erase that aspect of him and you lose something important.
Brett Booth Understands Speed
Whatever complaints I have about the story, I don’t have many complaints about how it looks. Brett Booth was a terrific choice for The Flash. His figures always seem to be moving even when they technically aren’t, and once Barry starts running, Booth’s kinetic style feels particularly well suited to the character. Norm Rapmund’s inks and Andrew Dalhouse’s colors help give the book an energetic visual identity that distinguishes this creative period from the Manapul era without making it feel disconnected from what came before.
Francis Manapul had previously been one of my favorite Flash artists for much the same reason. His layouts could communicate speed in ways that made Barry’s powers feel inventive instead of simply showing a guy with red motion lines behind him. Booth approaches the character differently. But he understands that a Flash comic should move. On that level, “Out of Time” absolutely moves. Sometimes I just wish the story knew where it was going.
When Time Travel Gets in the Way
Because eventually we have to deal with the damaged Speed Force. And alternate futures. And missing time. And Future Barry traveling backward while Wally becomes the Flash and pursues him. And a Speed Force rupture that needs to be repaired. And present Barry getting thrown somewhere completely outside his own time. This is where the storyline becomes more complicated than I think it needs to be.
I’m not opposed to complicated time travel. I love Back to the Future. My tolerance for temporal nonsense is well documented. But the emotional idea underneath “Out of Time” is much cleaner than the mythology surrounding it. Barry Allen cannot save everyone. That terrifies him. A future version of Barry refuses to accept that reality and destroys pieces of himself trying to correct every mistake. That is the story. Everything else should serve it.
Too often, I felt myself thinking about the mechanics of the Speed Force instead of the tragedy of Barry’s choices. When the fastest man alive discovers that he still arrives too late sometimes, you already have your hook. You don’t need to run circles around it.
What Out of Time Gets Right About the New 52
Looking back, “Out of Time” feels almost like a perfect example of my relationship with the New 52 itself. There are things I admire. The artwork is fantastic. Central City feels important. Barry’s forensic career matters. The central metaphor of the fastest man alive being unable to save everyone is exactly the kind of character-specific conflict a Flash story should explore. There are even ideas in this new Wally that work when I can separate him from the character whose name he inherited.
But there’s always something missing. For me, it’s legacy.
It’s the accumulated history that made the DC Universe feel like a place where generations of heroes had lived alongside one another. I understand why DC wanted a clean starting point in 2011. New readers shouldn’t need a doctorate in fictional continuity before buying issue #1. But there is a difference between making history accessible and pretending history never happened.
Maybe that’s why DC Rebirth connected with me in a way the New 52 often didn’t. It represented an acknowledgement that forward movement and respect for the past did not have to be enemies. Comic books change. They should. Jay Garrick gave way to Barry Allen. Barry gave way to Wally West. Barry eventually returned. New versions will come after all of them.
I don’t need every Flash story to look exactly like the comics I grew up reading. But if you’re going to ask me to run toward something new, don’t be surprised if I occasionally look over my shoulder at everything we left behind. Especially when I know Wally West is back there somewhere.