Buffy the Vampire Slayer: A Top Ten List

For those of you who may be unaware, I have a deep and abiding love for Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Part of me would like to say that this is merely limited to a mild crush on Sarah Michelle Gellar, but that’s just not it. In my humble opinion, it’s a brilliant TV show. Thanks to Joss Whedon’s creation of Buffy, I’ve chosen to give any of his work a chance, leading to a not quite as deep and abiding love for Angel, Firefly, and Dollhouse, all of which ended before their time.

On a side note, my friends Leo and Erynn once tried to convince me that Joss Whedon is not actually one person, but a conglomeration of individuals. Maybe they believe that one person couldn’t possibly come up with something as brilliant as Buffy the Vampire Slayer. I’d agree, but I’ve seen interviews. I’m pretty sure he’s a real guy.

Anyway, I’ve recently been rewatching Buffy on the Netflix. It’s interesting to go back to the beginning and watch how the actors and writers evolved over the seven years span of the series. And so, without further ado, I give you my ten favorite episodes…

10. Innocence – Season 2, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - InnocenceIt’s the one where Angel lost his soul and became the Big Bad that Buffy would face for the rest of the season. It’s bad enough that she had to deal with Spike and Drusilla, but then the love of her life turns to the dark side after a moment of true happiness. But even though watching Buffy get her heart broken was… well… heartbreaking… watching Angelus torment her and her friends was pretty much awesome. Angel was pretty depressing as a good guy, but as a bad guy he was all kinds of fun.

9. Prophecy Girl – Season 1, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - Prophecy GirlThis was the first season finale, in which Buffy finally faced The Master, her first real adversary. The ancient vampire escaped his mystical underground prison and attempted to open the Sunnydale Hellmouth, killing Buffy in the process. But she was only mostly dead. Xander was able to give her mouth-to-mouth and save her from drowning. She dusted The Master, the Hellmouth closed, and the day was saved. It was a good end to Buffy’s first year in Sunnydale.

8. Helpless – Season 3, written by David FuryBuffy Top Ten - HelplessAnd you thought I was just gonna pick Joss Whedon’s episodes. Buffy prepares to celebrate her 18th birthday by having her slayer powers taken away from her. The Watchers’ Council performs this test on all Slayers that reach their 18th birthday. The Slayer’s typical strength and reflexes are removed, then she’s placed in a difficult situation facing a dangerous vampire which she must slay relying only on her wits. What’s great about this episode is that it really strips Buffy down to who she is beyond being the Slayer. It also deeply explores her relationship with Giles, who proves to love Buffy like a father, rather than merely being her Watcher.

7. Restless – Season 4, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - RestlessThe fourth season finale had no Big Bad. The Scooby Gang beat him in the previous episode by performing a magic spell that ticked off the spirit of the first Slayer. The first Slayer then attacked our heroes in their dreams. In each dream, we saw a bit of each character’s fears and fantasies. And we found out a little more about the Slayer mythology, discovering a little more about what makes her tick.

6. Becoming, Part II – Season 2, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - BecomingIn the season 2 finale, Buffy was forced to kill Angel in order to stop an awakened demon from sucking the world into Hell. I know that sounds really complicated. But what it boils down to is that Buffy had to give up everything in her life to do what was right. In the end, she was fighting an evil Angelus without the support of her family or her friends. When Angel pointed this out to her, she realized that she was left with herself, the Slayer, which was more than enough to take out her former boyfriend. But just before she made the killing blow, Angel’s soul was restored. But Buffy still knew that Angel had to die in order to save the world. Slightly more heartbreaking than when Angel lost his soul in the first place. Maybe it was the moving number by Sarah McLachlan at the end while Buffy was riding a bus out of town.

5. Once More, With Feeling – Season 6, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - Once More with FeelingIt’s the musical episode. Like I wouldn’t put the musical episode in my top ten.

4. Earshot – Season 3, written by Jane EspensonBuffy Top Ten - EarshotAt the time, this was a pretty controversial episode. I guess even today it would be considered controversial, considering part of the plot revolves around a kid that brings a high powered rifle to school. Buffy gains the ability to hear people’s thoughts and hears someone’s thought that they’ll kill all the students in the school. The psychotic thinker turns out to be a crazy lunch lady. But Buffy is still able to reach out to Jonathan, a student that wants to commit suicide. Buffy learns, while hearing everyone’s innermost thoughts, that everyone deals with their own crap. Jonathan is whining about how no one notices him or even knows he exists, but Buffy knows that’s only because people are busy whining about their own pain, their own fears, their own insecurities. It’s a pretty good put-yourself-in-someone-else’s-shoes kind of lesson.

3. Passion – Season 2, written by Ty KingBuffy Top Ten - PassionThis is one that took place while Angel was still a bad guy. And in it, we see just how evil Angel really is. The writers weren’t playing around when they made him the Big Bad. Buffy’s boyfriend wasn’t just going through a phase, and they wanted the audience to know that he was seriously bad. Giles’ girlfriend, Ms. Calendar, was attempting to find a way to restore Angel’s soul, which would bring him back to the good guys. And as a way of thanking her for her trouble, Angel snapped her neck. Knowing that he was playing for keeps prepared Buffy for what she would have to do to stop him.

2. Hush – Season 4, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - HushMuch of this episode was done with zero dialogue, which was just an awesome way to get back at critics that claimed the show relied too heavily on dialogue. Everyone in Sunnydale has their voices stolen by a group of demonic creatures known as the Gentlemen: real creepy looking guys with permanent smiles plastered to their faces. They steal voices because a human scream can destroy them. Turns into a pretty nasty ending for them when Buffy gets her voice back.

1. The Body – Season 5, written by Joss WhedonBuffy Top Ten - The BodyThe death of Buffy’s mom, Joyce. She wasn’t killed by a vampire or a demon or some other supernatural entity. She died from an aneurysm, thanks to a complication from an earlier brain surgery. It was sudden and it was unexpected. Watching this episode again after losing a parent myself, it hit a little harder than the first time I saw it. It’s a great look at how each of the different characters express their feelings of loss when someone they know and love is suddenly gone.

16 thoughts on “Buffy the Vampire Slayer: A Top Ten List

  1. Omg I never knew you were such a fan! I personally never got into the shows myself. However, I was IN: Buffy, Angel and IN The Avengers as well. So I’ve literally been touching distance from Joss and I can testify that he’s just one regular guy, kinda goofy too. I could tell you things about the actors and actresses on Buffy and Angel that would utterly ruin the shows for you, but I won’t do that because I love you buddy! 😘

    So you can now say that you’re not even three degrees of separation away from Sarah Michelle Gellar and Joss Whedon!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Well… now you have to tell me when and where you show up on these shows so I can go back and see for myself! That’s awesome! And please, tell me whatever you want. I don’t think anything could possibly ruin my love for Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oh god it’s been at least 14 years since the last time I did one. I have NO idea which episodes I worked on lol! And I was always done up in different outfits and costumes, I highly doubt I’d recognize myself!
        Ok Sarah Michelle Gellar is hands down one of the RUDEST, most self-important, entitled, prissy, bossy, evil, and pretentious bitches I’ve EVER had the displeasure of working with. The dude who plays Angel, I always forget his damn name… is such a creep, he was always finding the absolute YOUNGEST girls on the set and trying to get them into his trailer. Total pedophile if you ask me. The coolest people, hands down, we’re the ones who played the demons or whatever in their crazy makeup and costumes. THEY were always very friendly and never were they full of themselves.
        Joss Whedon, I think he’s maybe autistic. Not that is a bad thing. But I think he’s got Aspergers autism..? Or maybe he’s slightly mentally retarded? Not too sure. I will say this, he’s listed as the director on a ton of shit, but I don’t think HE’S actually directing anything… I’ve watched him “directing” and I don’t think he was doing anything at all. I think his Co-director was running the show. It liked like an elaborate setup to make Joss think he was doing the directing. It was the strangest thing EVER!

        Liked by 1 person

      • Yeah that’s it. And I know Joss said that was a stand alone episode, but we re watched the series under the premise that it wasn’t a one-time thing and there is so much to support that notion! But I guess if you seek, you’ll find and all that 😛

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Day Three – The Confusing Middle

  3. Pingback: The Confusing Middle’s Top 10 Blog Posts of 2015 – The Confusing Middle

  4. Pingback: Rewatching Buffy – Episodes 28, 29, & 30 | The Confusing Middle

  5. Pingback: Rewatching Buffy – Episode 66 | The Confusing Middle

  6. Pingback: Rewatching Buffy – Episode 90 | The Confusing Middle

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s