Welcome back to Rewatching Smallville, my weekly dive into the iconic series that explores Clark Kent’s journey before becoming Superman. Whether you’re a long-time fan or new to the show, you’re invited to join in each Tuesday as I revisit episodes and share my thoughts and observations. Be sure to share your own memories and theories in the comments below!

There’s something deliciously ironic about an episode called “Talisman” that would become a cursed object for one of its own stars. The 64th episode of Smallville, which aired on May 5, 2004, serves as both a pivotal moment in the show’s mythology and a cautionary tale about what happens when you let Pa Kent behind the camera. But more on that production drama later – first, let’s dig into an episode that literally stabs Superman in the gut and asks some uncomfortable questions about destiny, power, and whether the hero of the story might actually be the villain.

When Ancient Prophecies Meet Modern Problems

“Talisman” opens with what has become a Smallville tradition: Lionel Luthor meddling with things that should probably be left alone. This time, he’s enlisted Professor Joseph Willowbrook (last seen in Season 2’s “Skinwalker”) and his eager graduate student Jeremiah Holdsclaw to examine a mysterious artifact in the Kawatche Caves. What they discover beneath the clay coating isn’t ancient cookware, as initially assumed, but a knife covered in Kryptonian symbols that glows ominously in Jeremiah’s hands.

The moment Jeremiah touches the blade – called “Palak” or the “starblade” in Kawatche legend – he gains powers remarkably similar to Clark’s. Super strength, super speed, heat vision, invulnerability – the whole package. There’s just one problem: the knife is meant to be wielded by Naman, “the man who fell from the stars,” and delivered to him by a protector. Jeremiah, convinced he IS Naman, decides to keep the blade and use it to fulfill what he believes is his destiny.

It’s a clever twist on the show’s usual formula. Instead of Clark facing off against a meteor-enhanced freak of the week, he’s confronting someone who’s been given powers by an ancient Kryptonian artifact – someone who might have a legitimate claim to being the prophesied hero. The episode forces both Clark and the audience to grapple with uncomfortable questions: What if you’re not the chosen one? What if someone else has a better claim to your destiny?

The Prophecy That Keeps On Giving (Anxiety)

The Kawatche prophecy that’s been bubbling in the background since Season 2 finally takes center stage here, and it’s not exactly the feel-good origin story Clark might have hoped for. According to the legend, Naman will be opposed by Sageeth, described as “a friend who becomes an enemy.” The prophecy foretells that one of them will kill the other, and that the starblade is the only weapon capable of killing Naman.

Professor Willowbrook, who continues to address Clark as Naman despite his protestations, delivers the episode’s most chilling line: “One who denies his destiny can bring about as much pain and suffering as your greatest enemy.” It’s a not-so-subtle reminder that Clark’s reluctance to embrace his role might be just as dangerous as any villain he faces.

The prophecy reaches its climax when both Lionel and Lex grab for the dissolving knife simultaneously, leaving Clark unable to determine which Luthor might be his prophesied enemy. It’s a moment that encapsulates the show’s central tension: Clark knows one of the most important people in his life is destined to become his greatest foe, but he doesn’t know which one. Talk about family dinner awkwardness.

Superman in a Red Blanket: Easter Eggs and Foreshadowing

For a show that spent its first few seasons religiously avoiding direct Superman references, “Talisman” is practically drunk on future-hero symbolism. The most obvious moment comes when Jonathan rips open Clark’s shirt to tend to his wound, revealing a blue undershirt underneath – a clear nod to the future Superman’s costume reveal. When Clark wakes up the next morning, he’s draped in a red blanket that unmistakably resembles a cape as he leaps up and runs off.

Even more subtly, the episode plays with the Clark Kent/Superman duality through Jeremiah’s character. In his “mild-mannered” graduate student identity, Jeremiah wears glasses – a detail that becomes meaningless once he gains superpowers. It’s a clever bit of parallel storytelling that hints at Clark’s own future double life.

Jonathan’s reassurance to Clark that he could be “the world’s greatest hero or its most mild-mannered citizen” is perhaps the episode’s most direct Superman reference, perfectly capturing the duality that will define Clark’s adult life. The fact that Jonathan believes Clark can be both – and that only Clark can write his own story – provides a hopeful counterpoint to all the dire prophecies swirling around his son.

The Directing Debut That Became a Directing Finale

Here’s where the behind-the-scenes drama gets juicy. “Talisman” marked John Schneider’s directorial debut on Smallville, making him the first regular cast member to step behind the camera. It was also, as it turns out, his directorial finale – though not by choice.

According to Schneider himself, revealed years later on the Talkville podcast, the producers called him after the episode aired to inform him he wouldn’t be allowed to direct again. The reason? A single scene between Lex and Lionel at the Luthor mansion. John Glover was still filming the previous episode and wasn’t available, so Schneider was forced to film Michael Rosenbaum and Glover separately, standing in different areas of the set.

The producers apparently felt this approach demonstrated that Schneider didn’t understand the relationship between the two characters. It’s a harsh judgment, especially considering that Schneider had been playing Jonathan Kent – a character defined by his relationship with his son – for three seasons. You’d think he might have some insight into complex family dynamics.

The episode also suffered from budget constraints and lost two days of filming due to the time and cost overruns from the previous episode, “Memoria.” So Schneider was essentially asked to perform directorial magic with less money and less time, then penalized when the results weren’t perfect. It’s the kind of Hollywood logic that would make Lionel Luthor proud.

Character Development in Crisis Mode

Beyond the mythology and behind-the-scenes drama, “Talisman” serves as a crucial character study, particularly for Clark. The episode finds him at his most vulnerable – not just physically (he literally gets stabbed and nearly dies), but emotionally and psychologically. He’s simultaneously being told he’s the savior of an entire people and being warned that he might become their greatest threat.

Clark’s conversation with Professor Willowbrook reveals his core struggle: “I just want to be Clark Kent.” It’s a line that encapsulates the show’s central conflict – the tension between who Clark is and who everyone expects him to become. Willowbrook’s response is characteristically blunt: “Jeremiah’s desperate to be someone he’s not. And you are desperate not to be someone you are.”

The episode also gives us crucial moments for other characters. Pete Ross, often relegated to comic relief, gets a genuine emotional storyline as he deals with his parents’ divorce and his mother’s potential move to Wichita. Lana faces her own crossroads with the Paris opportunity and the potential sale of the Talon. Even Lex gets some compelling material as he offers his own interpretation of the prophecy, suggesting that maybe Sageeth is actually the hero for keeping the potentially dangerous Naman in check.

The Mythology Deepens

“Talisman” represents a significant escalation in Smallville‘s mythology. Previous episodes had hinted at Clark’s alien heritage and destiny, but this episode makes it unavoidable. The Kawatche prophecy isn’t just ancient folklore – it’s starting to come true in uncomfortable ways.

The episode introduces the concept that Kryptonian artifacts can grant powers to humans, expanding the show’s mythology beyond meteor rocks and alien technology. The starblade’s ability to give Jeremiah Superman-like powers (including apparent immunity to kryptonite) suggests that Kryptonian influence on Earth goes back much further than anyone realized.

Most significantly, the episode establishes that Clark’s greatest enemy is already in his life – he just doesn’t know which one yet. The final scene, where both Lionel and Lex grab for the knife simultaneously, is a masterclass in dramatic irony. We know from decades of Superman lore that Lex is destined to become the villain, but Clark doesn’t. The uncertainty creates genuine tension and makes Clark’s continued friendship with Lex all the more poignant.

The Power of Choice vs. The Weight of Destiny

At its core, “Talisman” is about the conflict between destiny and free will. Jeremiah believes the prophecy gives him the right to claim powers and authority that aren’t his. Clark fears that the same prophecy will force him to become something he doesn’t want to be. The episode’s resolution suggests that both approaches are flawed.

Jeremiah’s downfall comes from his desperate desire to be the chosen one, leading him to commit increasingly violent acts in service of what he believes is his destiny. Clark’s struggle comes from his equally desperate desire to avoid his destiny, potentially causing the very suffering he’s trying to prevent.

Jonathan’s final advice to Clark – that he can write his own story – offers a third path. Destiny might set the stage, but individual choices determine the outcome. It’s a theme that will resonate throughout the series, as Clark learns to accept his heritage while defining his own heroic path.

Final Thoughts: A Talisman for the Series

“Talisman” stands as one of Smallville‘s most ambitious episodes, juggling prophecy, character development, and Superman mythology while dealing with production challenges behind the scenes. It’s an episode that asks big questions about power, responsibility, and the nature of heroism – questions that don’t have easy answers.

The episode’s lasting impact goes beyond its immediate story. It establishes the Luthor family as Clark’s prophesied enemies, sets up future conflicts around Clark’s alien heritage, and provides some of the series’ most direct Superman foreshadowing. It also serves as a reminder that even in a world of aliens and superpowers, the most interesting conflicts are often the most personal ones.

As for John Schneider’s brief directing career, “Talisman” stands as both a promising debut and a cautionary tale about the politics of television production. The episode he created, budget constraints and all, remains a fan favorite and a crucial piece of Smallville mythology.

In the end, “Talisman” succeeds because it understands that the most powerful talismans aren’t ancient artifacts or mystical weapons – they’re the choices we make and the relationships we build. Even if those relationships are destined to become complicated, painful, or downright adversarial, they’re still the things that define us.

And sometimes, they’re the things that get you fired from directing, but that’s Hollywood for you.