Bottom Line Up Front: Sixteen years later, DC’s ambitious death-and-resurrection epic remains the blueprint for how to simultaneously kill everyone and immediately regret it—while somehow managing to influence every major comic book event that followed.

Death Becomes Them

In 2009, DC Comics made a bold creative decision: What if we killed literally everyone and turned them into zombies? Not content with the usual comic book revolving door of death, Geoff Johns and Ivan Reis orchestrated Blackest Night, a crossover so comprehensive it made the Red Wedding look like a peaceful family dinner.

The premise was elegantly simple and utterly bonkers. Nekron, the literal embodiment of death, decided he was tired of all this “life” nonsense cluttering up his universe. His solution? Raise every dead superhero and villain as Black Lanterns—emotion-eating zombies with an unfortunate tendency to rip out hearts and spout ominous one-liners. Bruce Wayne got his skull stolen. The Elongated Man and Sue Dibny went from tragic murder victims to gleeful killers. Even the Spectre—God’s literal vengeance—got zombified.

The audacity was breathtaking. DC didn’t just kill a few C-listers for shock value; they systematically murdered their way through decades of emotional investment. Watching Hawkman and Hawkgirl—characters who’d been through more tragic deaths than a soap opera—get brutally killed by zombified versions of their friends was the kind of narrative cruelty that would make George R.R. Martin take notes.

The Emotional Spectrum Marketing Campaign

But Blackest Night wasn’t just about zombies in capes. Johns had been building toward this moment since Green Lantern: Rebirth, constructing an entire mythology around the emotional spectrum. Green for willpower, yellow for fear, red for rage—and suddenly, DC had a rainbow of ring-slinging space cops, each more merchandisable than the last.

The brilliance lay in the simplicity: emotions as superpowers. It was Inside Out six years before Pixar thought of it, except with more disembowelment. Each color represented not just a different corps but a different storytelling approach. The Red Lanterns vomited acidic blood when angry (because subtlety is for cowards), while the Blue Lanterns powered up through hope (because sometimes even dark comic events need a hug).

This emotional framework became DC’s Swiss Army knife for future storytelling. Need to explore trauma? Red Lanterns. Want to examine corruption? Yellow Lanterns of fear. Feeling optimistic about quarterly sales? Blue Lanterns to the rescue.

The White Light Cop-Out

Then came Brightest Day, the direct follow-up that asked the burning question: “Remember all those characters we just killed? What if we… didn’t?”

If Blackest Night was DC’s winter, Brightest Day was their spring cleaning—assuming your idea of spring cleaning involves mysteriously resurrecting twelve specific dead characters and then spending twenty-five issues figuring out why. The White Light of creation had returned Aquaman, Martian Manhunter, Hawkman, Hawkgirl, Firestorm, and others to life, each with a cosmic assignment that ranged from “close interdimensional portals” to “throw a boomerang at Dove” (seriously, that was Captain Boomerang’s mission).

The follow-up’s central theme of “second chances” sounds noble until you realize it’s essentially DC admitting they killed characters they still wanted to use. It’s the comic book equivalent of taking back a particularly vindictive text message, except the text message involved cosmic death gods and required a year-long publishing commitment to retract.

The New 52 Betrayal

Here’s where the story gets genuinely insulting to reader intelligence. Brightest Day ended in April 2011. The New 52 reboot launched in September 2011. DC spent a year carefully resurrecting characters and exploring their new purposes, then immediately hit the reset button and erased it all anyway.

Imagine spending two years watching an elaborate magic trick, applauding the reveal, then watching the magician set his cards on fire and claim it was all a warm-up. The New 52 didn’t just undermine Brightest Day—it retroactively made the entire emotional investment feel like a cynical cash grab.

Maxwell Lord’s resurrection and the exploration of his mind-control powers? Gone. Aquaman’s relationship with the new Aqualad? Rebooted. The careful character development of Firestorm’s dual identity crisis? Erased. DC had pulled off one of the most ambitious death-and-resurrection narratives in comics history, then decided none of it mattered.

The Template for Modern Event Fatigue

The Blackest Night/Brightest Day cycle established a template that DC has been religiously following ever since:

1. Build up cosmic threat over multiple years
2. Kill lots of characters for emotional impact
3. Bring them back with cosmic explanation
4. Reset universe when things get too complicated
5. Repeat until readership develops emotional calluses

Dark Nights: Metal and Death Metal followed this playbook so closely they might as well have been spiritual sequels. Heroes in Crisis tried to subvert it by keeping the deaths permanent, only to face such backlash that DC started walking back casualties within months.

James Gunn’s current approach to the DCU shows he’s learned from these mistakes, specifically noting that “if a character dies, such character will most likely stay dead” unless resurrection serves the story rather than convenience. It’s almost as if someone at DC finally realized that death without consequence is just expensive theater.

Current Relevance: The All In Initiative

DC’s current “All In” initiative, launching with the Absolute Universe, represents another attempt to recapture the Blackest Night magic without repeating its mistakes. Instead of killing everyone, they’re creating alternative versions where Batman has no money, Superman has no family, and Wonder Woman has no paradise island.

It’s a clever solution: you get the shock of familiar characters in unfamiliar circumstances without the emotional manipulation of fake deaths. Scott Snyder’s Absolute Batman presents “a version of the Dark Knight that doesn’t have the money, mansion, or butler of his core-line counterpart,” which is infinitely more interesting than “Batman but dead and evil.”

The addition of Absolute Martian Manhunter to the lineup feels particularly pointed—here’s a character who was meaningfully resurrected in Brightest Day, only to be immediately sidelined by the New 52. The Absolute Universe offers a do-over without the baggage of past editorial decisions.

The Lasting Legacy

Despite the New 52 betrayal, Blackest Night and Brightest Day fundamentally changed how DC approaches mythology. The emotional spectrum concept has become as integral to Green Lantern as Kryptonite is to Superman. The idea that death should serve thematic purpose rather than shock value has slowly—very slowly—crept into DC’s editorial consciousness.

More importantly, these events proved that readers will invest emotionally in cosmic-scale storytelling if you respect their intelligence. The problem was never the ambition; it was the follow-through. Blackest Night succeeded because it felt inevitable—the culmination of years of careful building. Brightest Day faltered because it felt obligatory—a corporate mandate to undo what had just been done.

The Future of Heroic Death

The upcoming “DC K.O.” event promises “32 fighters will enter the tournament of champions,” which sounds suspiciously like another attempt to systematically eliminate the cast. But perhaps DC has learned something from fifteen years of criticism.

The real test isn’t whether they can craft another universe-threatening crisis—it’s whether they can resist the urge to immediately undo it afterward. The future of heroes isn’t about who can die most dramatically or return most mysteriously. It’s about whether publishers can commit to the consequences of their storytelling choices.

Blackest Night and Brightest Day remain fascinating reads, not because they solved the problem of death in comics, but because they so thoroughly illustrated why the problem exists in the first place. They’re cautionary tales disguised as cosmic epics—proof that killing everyone is easy, but living with the aftermath requires actual courage.

In the end, the blackest night wasn’t the zombie apocalypse. It was the editorial decision to throw it all away six months later.

---

What character resurrection would you most like to see, and how do you think DC should handle death in comics going forward? Share your thoughts in the comments below—just remember that in comics, even our opinions might get retconned eventually.