Welcome back to Rewatching Smallville, my weekly dive into the iconic series that explores Clark Kent’s journey before becoming Superman. Whether you’re a long-time fan or new to the show, you’re invited to join in each Tuesday as I revisit episodes and share my thoughts and observations. Be sure to share your own memories and theories in the comments below!

If you’ve ever wondered what would happen if someone gave Lionel Luthor superpowers, “Transference” provides the deeply unsettling answer: absolutely nothing good. It’s an episode that takes the relatively simple concept of a body swap and transforms it into psychological horror, workplace harassment seminar, and family therapy session all rolled into one supremely uncomfortable hour of television.

Twenty-one years later, “Transference” remains one of Smallville‘s most disturbing episodes—not because of meteor freaks or alien threats, but because it forces us to watch Clark’s pure intentions twisted into something predatory and cruel. It’s also a masterclass in acting, as Tom Welling and John Glover essentially have to become each other while maintaining their own physical performances. The result is an episode that’s simultaneously fascinating and deeply creepy, which feels like the perfect description of Lionel Luthor himself.

Plus, we finally get confirmation that Lionel’s interest in Martha Kent goes way beyond friendly neighborly concern, and honestly, we could have lived without that particular revelation.

The Master and the Student: Glover and Welling’s Performance Challenge

Let’s start with what makes “Transference” work despite its inherently soap opera-ish premise: the absolutely committed performances from John Glover and Tom Welling. Body swap episodes are notoriously difficult to pull off because they require actors to essentially do impressions of each other while maintaining their own physical presence, and somehow both actors manage to nail this impossible balancing act.

Tom Welling’s performance as Lionel-in-Clark’s-body is nothing short of masterful. He doesn’t just adopt Lionel’s physical mannerisms—he inhabits the character so completely that you genuinely forget you’re watching Glover. When “Clark” tells Martha he needs a hug and then becomes visibly aroused during their embrace, triggering Clark’s heat vision, it’s one of the most disturbing moments in the entire series. Welling plays it with just enough restraint that it feels genuinely threatening without becoming unwatchable.

What makes Welling’s performance so effective is how he captures Lionel’s predatory intelligence operating through Clark’s innocent exterior. When he tells Chloe he finds her “fascinating” and moves in for a kiss before cruelly pulling away with “Don’t you wish,” it’s Lionel’s psychological manipulation filtered through Clark’s trusted persona. The violation isn’t just physical—it’s the corruption of relationships built on years of trust and affection.

The scene where Lionel-as-Clark forces himself on Lana is genuinely hard to watch, and Welling deserves credit for playing it as disturbing rather than titillating. When Lana slaps him and storms off, you can see Lionel’s satisfaction with the chaos he’s creating, and it’s a reminder that for all his sophisticated presentation, Lionel is fundamentally a destroyer of innocence.

John Glover faces the arguably more difficult challenge of playing Clark’s essential decency while trapped in Lionel’s deteriorating body. His performance as Clark-in-Lionel’s-body works because he doesn’t try to mimic Welling’s vocal patterns or physical mannerisms—instead, he finds ways to convey Clark’s moral certainty and emotional vulnerability through Lionel’s weary frame.

The scene where Clark-as-Lionel convinces Martha he’s really her son is a particular highlight. Glover’s delivery of the story about six-year-old Clark getting lost in Palmer Woods feels genuine and heartfelt, and you can see Martha’s recognition dawning as she realizes this really is her son. It’s a touching moment that provides emotional relief from the horror of watching Lionel corrupt Clark’s relationships.

Glover also brings appropriate urgency to Clark’s powerless state in prison. Without his abilities, Clark becomes genuinely vulnerable for one of the few times in the series, and Glover plays the fear and frustration convincingly. When the large convict threatens him and Clark can’t fight back, it’s a stark reminder of how much Clark has come to rely on his powers for protection.

The Production Challenge: Making Body Swaps Believable

From a technical standpoint, “Transference” faces the challenge of making the body swap visually convincing while maintaining story momentum. The sequence where Clark and Lionel’s spirits literally swirl and merge is appropriately mystical without becoming ridiculous, and the show wisely keeps the magical elements brief and focused.

The real production challenge comes in the scenes where the actors have to convincingly portray each other’s mannerisms. According to the Season 4 DVD commentary, Glover would act out scenes while Welling observed, then they would switch so Welling could imitate Glover’s performance. It’s a testament to both actors’ skill that this process resulted in such seamless characterizations.

The episode also benefits from smart costuming choices that help sell the personality changes. When Martha notices “Clark” wearing dress shirts and slacks instead of his usual flannel, it’s a visual cue that something is fundamentally different. Similarly, the way Lionel-as-Clark carries himself—more confident and predatory than Clark’s usual earnest posture—helps establish the character switch without relying solely on dialogue.

Director James Marshall deserves credit for finding ways to make the inherently silly premise feel genuinely threatening. The pacing never lets the audience get comfortable with the situation, and the mounting sense of violation as Lionel corrupts Clark’s relationships creates real dramatic tension rather than just novelty.

Mythology and the Crystal of Water

“Transference” serves important functions in Season 4’s broader mythology, particularly regarding the Stones of Power and Clark’s growing understanding of his Kryptonian heritage. The revelation that the body-swapping stone is actually the Crystal of Water provides crucial setup for the season’s climactic events while demonstrating how dangerous these artifacts can be in the wrong hands.

Clark’s explanation that he was drawn to the stone “just like he was as Kal-El” suggests that his Kryptonian programming recognizes these artifacts as significant, even when his conscious mind doesn’t understand their purpose. It’s an interesting development that hints at the ongoing tension between Clark’s human upbringing and his alien destiny.

The episode also advances our understanding of Lionel’s research into Kryptonian history. The wall of articles and research about the Stones of Power in his prison cell reveals the depth of his obsession with these artifacts and suggests he’s been planning something like this body swap for quite some time. His partnership with Edgar Cole, the linguistics expert, shows that Lionel’s approach to the supernatural is characteristically methodical and manipulative.

Edgar’s revelation that the transference was originally intended for Lex adds another layer to Lionel’s schemes. The plan to trap Lex in prison while Lionel escaped in his son’s body is exactly the kind of cold, calculating manipulation we’d expect from Lionel. It also raises questions about how long Lionel has been planning to betray his own son.

The appearance of Bridgette Crosby at the episode’s end, collecting the Crystal of Water from Edgar, connects this episode to the broader Jor-El storyline while suggesting that Clark isn’t the only one interested in gathering these powerful artifacts. Her presence hints at larger forces at work that Clark doesn’t yet understand.

Supporting Characters and Relationship Dynamics

The episode works particularly well in how it uses the body swap to stress-test Clark’s established relationships. Watching Lionel manipulate and violate the trust Clark has built with his friends and family is genuinely upsetting, but it also demonstrates the strength of those bonds.

Chloe’s reaction to “Clark’s” cruel behavior toward her is heartbreaking, particularly because she has no way to understand what’s really happening. Allison Mack brings real vulnerability to Chloe’s confusion and hurt, and her suggestion that Clark should “get psychological help” feels like a reasonable response to what appears to be a complete personality change.

Lana’s anger and confusion about “Clark’s” behavior creates interesting dramatic irony, since the audience knows she’s responding to Lionel’s violations rather than anything Clark actually did. Kristin Kreuk plays Lana’s hurt and anger convincingly, and her demand that Clark keep quiet about her relationship with Jason takes on additional weight when we know Clark has no idea what she’s referring to.

The episode also provides some of the best Martha and Jonathan material of the season. Annette O’Toole’s performance when Martha realizes she’s been interacting with Lionel-in-Clark’s-body is genuinely disturbing, particularly given Lionel’s long-standing inappropriate interest in her. John Schneider brings appropriate protective anger to Jonathan’s scenes, and his physical confrontation with Lionel-as-Clark provides visceral satisfaction.

Lex’s paranoid testing of Clark at the episode’s end demonstrates how the body swap has damaged even his relationship with his closest friend. Michael Rosenbaum plays Lex’s suspicion and eventual relief perfectly, and the callback to their first meeting in the pilot provides nice continuity while showing how much their relationship has evolved.

The Darker Implications of Power

What makes “Transference” particularly effective is how it explores the corrupting influence of power through Lionel’s use of Clark’s abilities. When Lionel discovers he can lift the tractor, his immediate thought isn’t about helping others—it’s about the opportunities this strength provides for personal gain and manipulation.

The episode suggests that Clark’s heroic nature isn’t just a product of his moral upbringing, but also stems from his fundamental character. Given the same abilities, Lionel immediately uses them for selfish and predatory purposes, highlighting the choices Clark makes every day to be better than his raw power would allow.

Lionel’s attempted access to his foreign bank accounts while in Clark’s body provides dark comedy while illustrating his priorities. Even with godlike abilities at his disposal, his first concern is recovering his financial assets. It’s a perfect encapsulation of how small-minded Lionel’s villainy really is, despite his grandiose presentation.

The episode also deals with the uncomfortable reality of what happens when someone with Lionel’s mindset gains access to super-strength and invulnerability. His casual violence toward Jonathan and his predatory behavior toward the women in Clark’s life feel genuinely threatening because there’s nothing anyone can do to stop him.

Cultural Context and Uncomfortable Truths

“Transference” aired during a period when Smallville was beginning to grapple with more adult themes while still maintaining its family-friendly rating. The episode’s handling of Lionel’s predatory behavior toward Martha and his harassment of Chloe and Lana feels particularly relevant to contemporary discussions about abuse of power and workplace harassment.

The show deserves credit for treating these violations seriously rather than playing them for comedy. Lionel’s behavior is consistently presented as threatening and wrong, and the episode never suggests that his actions are justified or understandable. It’s a surprisingly mature handling of disturbing subject matter for a show that often struggled with tonal consistency.

The episode also explores themes of identity and authenticity that feel relevant to early 2000s anxieties about online personas and digital identity. Lionel’s ability to literally become someone else while retaining his essential nature raises questions about how much of our identity is tied to our physical presence versus our fundamental character.

The Healing Factor and New Mysteries

One of the episode’s most intriguing developments comes at the very end, when it’s revealed that Lionel’s liver disease has been completely cured by his time in Clark’s body. This opens up fascinating questions about the healing properties of Kryptonian physiology while providing Lionel with renewed health and energy for future schemes.

The healing also creates an interesting parallel to Clark’s own invulnerability. Just as Clark’s powers protect him from most forms of harm, his healing abilities apparently extend to anyone temporarily inhabiting his body. It’s a development that makes Clark’s physiology even more miraculous while suggesting that these abilities could potentially benefit others under the right circumstances.

Lionel’s claim to have no memory of his time in Clark’s body provides convenient cover for his actions while maintaining the character’s plausible deniability. Whether he’s telling the truth or simply protecting himself from consequences remains an open question that adds to his mystique.

Technical Achievement and Series Evolution

“Transference” represents Smallville at its most technically ambitious, successfully pulling off a complex premise that could have easily become ridiculous. The episode demonstrates the series’ growing confidence in tackling challenging concepts while maintaining its established tone and character dynamics.

The special effects work, while limited, serves the story effectively without overwhelming it. The brief supernatural elements feel appropriately mystical while keeping the focus on character interactions and emotional consequences. It’s a approach that serves the series well throughout its run.

The episode also showcases the strength of Smallville‘s ensemble cast, as every major character gets meaningful scenes that advance their individual storylines while serving the central body swap plot. It’s the kind of unified storytelling that made the series’ best episodes feel like essential viewing rather than simple entertainment.

Why “Transference” Endures

“Transference” succeeds because it uses its supernatural premise to explore genuinely disturbing questions about power, corruption, and violation of trust. The episode doesn’t shy away from the uncomfortable implications of its central concept, and the result is an hour of television that stays with you long after the credits roll.

The episode also benefits from absolutely committed performances from its lead actors, who sell an inherently ridiculous premise through sheer force of conviction and skill. Watching Glover and Welling essentially trade characters while maintaining their own physical presence is a master class in television acting.

Most importantly, “Transference” understands that the real horror isn’t in the supernatural body swap itself, but in watching someone use Clark’s trusted relationships for manipulation and harm. It’s a violation that feels personal and disturbing in ways that typical villain schemes never quite achieve.

The episode serves as a crucial turning point in Clark’s understanding of how his powers could be misused, while advancing the season’s mythology in meaningful ways. By the end, Clark has gained new appreciation for the responsibility that comes with his abilities, while Lionel has gained renewed health and energy for whatever schemes he’s planning next.

The Verdict

“Transference” stands as one of Season 4’s most successful episodes, taking a potentially silly premise and transforming it into genuine psychological horror through committed performances and smart writing. It’s an episode that works both as supernatural thriller and character study, providing disturbing insights into power dynamics while advancing multiple ongoing storylines.

The episode represents Smallville at its most daring, willing to explore dark themes and uncomfortable implications while never losing sight of the human emotions driving the story forward. It’s also a showcase for the series’ two strongest actors, who rise to the challenge of essentially playing each other while maintaining their own distinct physical presence.

The real success of “Transference” lies in how it deepens our understanding of both Clark and Lionel while advancing the season’s central mythology. By showing us what Clark’s powers look like in the wrong hands, the episode reinforces everything that makes him heroic while setting up future conflicts in meaningful ways.

Just maybe don’t accept any mysterious glowing stones from Lionel Luthor, no matter how dying and pathetic he appears to be. Some gifts come with strings attached that are a lot more literal than you might expect.

What did you think of the body swap premise when “Transference” first aired? Did Tom Welling and John Glover’s performances convince you they had actually switched characters? And how did you feel about seeing Clark’s relationships violated in such a personal way? Share your thoughts and memories in the comments below!